Fine. I disagree with pretty much everyone. I see nothing wrong with that whatsoever. It wasn't 1 on 1 in a gun duel. It was football. It was team building, including for the kid. The kid showed guts by taking his tongue lashing and 1 on 1's and everyone was cool with him afterwards because he accepted it and apologized. And we were freaking 13 years old. I honestly don't get what was wrong with the punishment in this case specifically. It is what it is.
I guess it's similar to if my kid lipped off to a bigger, older kid because he thought that the kid wouldn't smack him...and he gets smacked. If he comes home crying to me about it, I'm gonna tell him he had it coming. There are consequences, and you can't get bailed out of everything in the real world. Parents today IMO are doing kids a huge injustice by handicapping them in this regard.