Northside Hawk
Well-Known Member
Van Halen made the change at the mic absolutely at the pinnacle of their career. AC/DC, in different circumstances, was near their pinnacle. Pink Floyd was early in their run, you can't quite say they were just getting started. Genesis was not yet at their commercial peak but may have been at their artistic peak. I preferred Dio era in Black Sabbath to Ozzy's era in high school but learned to love Ozzy shortly thereafter and forever onwards.They definitely had a nice run. It's rare to see a mega-band replace its lead singer and maintain that momentum (AC/DC comes to mind).
In VH's case, a little luck was involved. Eddie wasn't the easiest guy to work with and his worsening alcoholism and mood swings just made it worse. If Sammy hadn't taken the job pretty much on a whim, they probably would have had a difficult time finding anyone of quality willing to put up with it.
To this day, I still think Van Halen would have gone down as one of the all-time greats if Eddie had stayed reasonably sober and stuck with lead guitar instead of obsessing with the keyboards and synthesizer.
They were my first concert. On their debut tour, I saw them at the 5-Flags Center in Dubuque. I think it was '79.
Other formidable but not quite mega-bands would include Journey, Kansas, and Iron Maiden. And you could argue that Kansas wasn't the same after Steve Walsh.