1. Dan Gable - Nobody has dominated any sport in the way Gable has, not only as a wrestler, but also as a coach...no comparision.
2. Chow - American coaches don't have more than one gymnast with chances to be repeat World Champions, let alone Olympic champions...Chow has that in Douglas, plus he turned Johnson into a sensational gymnast. This doesn't happen in American gymnastics.
3. Feller - What could he have done without essentially losing his prime to fight for his country?
For others on the list like Warner, yeah he accomplished a lot, even took the Cardinals of all people to the Super Bowl...pretty big.
Kinnick, the most prestigeous trophy in college football, it was a real award when he won it and is very impressive.
To the Harrison Barnes haters out there...no incoming freshman had ever been voted to be a pre-season all-american...not unrealistic expectations at all. He had a couple injuries in his career, but was by no means a bust. Barnes is a very good player, who will have a long NBA career...will he be a HOF'er, probably not, but he will be an All-Star at some point in his career. If he would have done the same thing at Iowa, he would be praised on here...he has issues with his game, but he is by no means a bust.