Biggest Concerns Following Saturday's Scrimmage

iowalaw

Banned
1. Now that the QB situation is settled and big armed CJ is the starter with free reign over the offense, I think most of us expected to see an improved, higher octane offense. Yet, with CJ at the helm going up against a defense that got absolutely slaughtered in the bowl game, CJ's offense put up ZERO points? That does not bode well.

2. With Brian Ferentz at the helm at the OL and some pretty miserable recruiting in the past four years, our OL is a patchwork of walk ons and guys with no major offers. It showed on Saturday. RBs had no holes to run through. QBs had little time to throw. There is no magic pill that will fix the OL. They are under coached and under talented. While our RBs have potential, all the potential in the world won't get them anywhere if the OL can't open some holes. CJ can have a cannon, but it won't matter if he's getting sacked.

3. Punter. Are you serious? This is the THIRD year in a row where we have zero talent at the punter position, and it's unacceptable. We have TWO scholarship punters who can't kick the ball more than 38 yards, and they get no hang time relative to other college punters. The best punter on the team is our placekicker, who hasn't been practicing punting day in and day out for 4 years like our two scholarship guys. How could the staff have missed so hard on punters. This is one position that is easy to scout. How could there be so little player development at this position. Don't these guys practice?

4. WRs. Yet another year with no separation at all. No burners. Just a bunch of possession guys. I don't care how many times our #1 WR can catch the ball with one hand in a minute. How many times can he get open against Big 10 QBs in a game. That is all that matters. Where is the WR depth that Davis was supposed to be building over the past 4 years? Our #2, Vandenberg, had another ball thrown that hit him right in the hands, that he dropped on Sat. I give the guy credit for overachieving and being a starter on a Big 10 team...but he's maxed out his potential. We could clearly use an upgrade at the position and I am baffled why we didn't bring in a JUCO last year to compete. Willies would have made us all forget Vandenberg was on the roster this year.

5. #2 QB Development. Wiegers, a 4 star QB who was the #14 QB in his class at that position, was our highest rated commit two years ago. By all accounts, he struggled mightily with the very basic QB fundamentals like handling snaps, staying steady in the pocket, and having proper QB mechanics. I get that he's inexperienced, but in this day and age, a 4 star redshirt frosh QB is expected to perform, and not be coddled. Manzel won the Heisman in 2012 as a 3 star redshirt frosh. Jameis Winston won the Heisman in 2013 as a freshmen. OSU won the national championship in 2014 with a freshmen QB. It's time for Wiegers to put on his big boy pants and perform like a Big 10 QB. If not, we are going to see Boyle climb to the #2 position by the end of the season.

6. Steve Ferentz getting center reps? What is with the rumor I'm hearing that Steve Ferentz is getting a bunch of reps at Center? Haven't we been down this road one too many times? The highest rated recruit we have had in the past 4 years graduated from high school early and turned down Alabama, Auburn, Mich, etc. so that he could move to Iowa to be a Hawk. If he winds up 4th string behind a 1* walkon who happens to be the coach's son on the depth chart, that will be an absolute killer to team morale. I'm hoping this is just a rumor and that, if Daniels chooses not to redshirt, he is given a fair shot at playing time this year.

On the plus side, it sounds like our defense has, in fact, taken the step forward that was needed. DL looks to be improved and the LBs seem better. We have a corner who could be 1st team all Big 10, which will take some pressure off the secondary. It also looks like we have a solid kicker this year, after last year's place kicking started off pretty scary. Who is going to return kicks and punts? I hope the staff opens it up and lets people try out. We need our special teams to be a weapon again, not a fair catching clinic.
 
LOL @ the op. I'm sure you as a Cyclone fan were at the scrimmage. Almost none of what you said is accurate. And this is from someone who was actually at the scrimmage.
 
Time will tell but I'm convinced and have always been convinced it's Davis. If there is any a year to prove me wrong it's this season, since some seem to think CJ is who Davis prefers at QB.
 
Time will tell but I'm convinced and have always been convinced it's Davis. If there is any a year to prove me wrong it's this season, since some seem to think CJ is who Davis prefers at QB.

Trust me, it's Davis. When you lead guided tours of the new facility and throw former players under the bus, one thing stands out: that person is a POS. That person lead the tour and saying that? Davis.

I support KF. If Davis is around after this season, and this season plays out like another typical Davis season (running against teams with poor pass D, dominating in run game but abandoning so we can pass 46 plays in a row, oodles and scads of let's-see-if-we-can-spring-a-possession-receiver-in-the-flat), I fully support unceremoniously bagging KF If it's another Davis season and KF bags Davis, he buys another year with me, PLUS burns another season worth of buyout bucks in the bargain.

And if one more person defends Davis in any way/shape/form and mentions a Texas NC, I will personally invite them to a blanket party.

I liked Jake, nothing against CJB (other than The Interview), but know that Davis would have even ruined the 2002 Hawk offense.
 
LOL @ the op. I'm sure you as a Cyclone fan were at the scrimmage. Almost none of what you said is accurate. And this is from someone who was actually at the scrimmage.

I'm beginning to think the OP is a Clown troll as well, as it is obvious he didnt go to the scrimmage
 
Interesting that the OP is being called a troll yet some of his points are very hard to argue with. There may be a more PC way to state those viewpoints certainly but the offense in general is in rough shape and has been the better part of the last 15 years. On top of that we have an OL that is getting dominated by a DL that a mid-tier SEC team humbled a few months ago.
 
Trust me, it's Davis. When you lead guided tours of the new facility and throw former players under the bus, one thing stands out: that person is a POS. That person lead the tour and saying that? Davis.

I support KF. If Davis is around after this season, and this season plays out like another typical Davis season (running against teams with poor pass D, dominating in run game but abandoning so we can pass 46 plays in a row, oodles and scads of let's-see-if-we-can-spring-a-possession-receiver-in-the-flat), I fully support unceremoniously bagging KF If it's another Davis season and KF bags Davis, he buys another year with me, PLUS burns another season worth of buyout bucks in the bargain.

And if one more person defends Davis in any way/shape/form and mentions a Texas NC, I will personally invite them to a blanket party.

I liked Jake, nothing against CJB (other than The Interview), but know that Davis would have even ruined the 2002 Hawk offense.



please elaborate on your first paragraph
 
Trust me, it's Davis. When you lead guided tours of the new facility and throw former players under the bus, one thing stands out: that person is a POS. That person lead the tour and saying that? Davis.

I support KF. If Davis is around after this season, and this season plays out like another typical Davis season (running against teams with poor pass D, dominating in run game but abandoning so we can pass 46 plays in a row, oodles and scads of let's-see-if-we-can-spring-a-possession-receiver-in-the-flat), I fully support unceremoniously bagging KF If it's another Davis season and KF bags Davis, he buys another year with me, PLUS burns another season worth of buyout bucks in the bargain.

And if one more person defends Davis in any way/shape/form and mentions a Texas NC, I will personally invite them to a blanket party.

I liked Jake, nothing against CJB (other than The Interview), but know that Davis would have even ruined the 2002 Hawk offense.


Ive heard this. Just never seen anyone post it.
 
Last edited:
Trust me, it's Davis. When you lead guided tours of the new facility and throw former players under the bus, one thing stands out: that person is a POS. That person lead the tour and saying that? Davis.

I support KF. If Davis is around after this season, and this season plays out like another typical Davis season (running against teams with poor pass D, dominating in run game but abandoning so we can pass 46 plays in a row, oodles and scads of let's-see-if-we-can-spring-a-possession-receiver-in-the-flat), I fully support unceremoniously bagging KF If it's another Davis season and KF bags Davis, he buys another year with me, PLUS burns another season worth of buyout bucks in the bargain.

And if one more person defends Davis in any way/shape/form and mentions a Texas NC, I will personally invite them to a blanket party.

I liked Jake, nothing against CJB (other than The Interview), but know that Davis would have even ruined the 2002 Hawk offense.

Soo funny that you protect kirk. Its gotta be davis it just has to be. If this same stuff happens for another 5 years then blame kirk.
 
I remember when KOK was the epitome of everything wrong with Iowa football.

We had a worse offense back then. Same person hired both them and ran both teams.
 
Trust me, it's Davis. When you lead guided tours of the new facility and throw former players under the bus, one thing stands out: that person is a POS. That person lead the tour and saying that? Davis.

I support KF. If Davis is around after this season, and this season plays out like another typical Davis season (running against teams with poor pass D, dominating in run game but abandoning so we can pass 46 plays in a row, oodles and scads of let's-see-if-we-can-spring-a-possession-receiver-in-the-flat), I fully support unceremoniously bagging KF If it's another Davis season and KF bags Davis, he buys another year with me, PLUS burns another season worth of buyout bucks in the bargain.

And if one more person defends Davis in any way/shape/form and mentions a Texas NC, I will personally invite them to a blanket party.

I liked Jake, nothing against CJB (other than The Interview), but know that Davis would have even ruined the 2002 Hawk offense.

Vince Young won that NC for Texas, not Davis or Mack.

Davis got run from Texas with much better talent and in a league that didn't believe in defense outside of OU, and Texas, somewhat.
 
It's always been KF. It's just compounded more now that he's hired worse coaches to replace the ones who saved his butt
 
I remember when KOK was the epitome of everything wrong with Iowa football.

We had a worse offense back then. Same person hired both them and ran both teams.

I didn't have a problem with KoKs offense. Like any OC, he some times mixed plays in a way that raised eyebrows, but he maximized the talent, for the most part. He never grumbled about what personnel Iowa did NOT have. He never blamed players, publicly or during guided tours. And when a play call didn't work, he had enough of the respect of his HC for the HC to take the blame.

Now? KF mentioned not even being in on offensive discussions/sessions during one of last season's pressers. Frankly, that's when I thought GD would be gone. The fact he isn't does more to displease me than with KF than just about anything else.
 

Latest posts

Top