Dunking in itself doesn’t necessarily make one a better player. However when a 6’1 Hs junior PG starts throwing down dunks it’s tells you a lot about his explosiveness. Do you recall the Anthony Clemmons story? When he was playing AAU he wasn’t getting recruited by anyone, until one game he rose up and dunked over a big man. The coach said after the game he had tons of messages from college coaches asking about Clemmons. Those are people that get paid to do this.
As far as the comparison as players goes. The only similarities I see is that they are both lefties from Iowa. DJ is a slasher scorer and Connor liked to play in the pick and roll and facilitate.
Lastly the water bug PG argument makes me want to puke, it’s so tired. Glyn Watson was probably the quickest PG in the B1G last year, but nowhere near the best. Rememberr Trey Dickerson? What we want is a very good player at the PG position who is athletic and can make plays for himself and others. DJ Carton fits the bill, every P5 school in the Midwest and soon likely many more across the country agree. I think you are off on this one.
I was going to bring up the Clemmons story too, but for a slightly different reason. It's funny that Clemmons had one dunk where the stars aligned perfectly, and that's all it took for people to think more of him. Soooo overrated. He was still the exact same player after that dunk and he went through 4 years of college without really showing the athleticism that he displayed on that one dunk.