Marcel Joly

Status
Not open for further replies.
So what are we talking about? GSR or ACT? Talk about a pivot.

I have zero problem with blacks, I don't like you because you're a coward who resorts to name-calling instead of providing evidence like an adult.

Dude you took what I said and tried to make it false naming a matrix with noting to do with race.
 
Compare to other schools. Iowa would be dismal in the SEC.
You, verbatim.
According to the NCAA themselves, using this website:

https://web3.ncaa.org/aprsearch/gsrsearch

That would be false as well.

Numbers only go to 2012, but even then, Iowa's numbers were on a 4 year upward trend, with our 2012 GSR being 85.

That would have tied for third in the SEC with Alabama, being behind only Vanderbilt (95) and South Carolina (92)
Me, verbatim.

And again, you threw another hissy fit accusing me of being a racist.

All because you can't handle actually doing research before opening your mouth.
 
What does the graduation rate look like for all students at Iowa? What does the graduation rate look like for all black students at Iowa? ( should look at 5 years of attendance, not 4). Compare football black athletes to all scholarship athletes. Compare ACT’s at Iowa only to schools who have legislative priorities for State residents’ admissions. Compare family income of black athletes to all students, or non-minority students on athletic scholarship. Do longer term follow up studies on whatever measures of success after graduation you may want to use. Explain to me how you define “academics” at Iowa as some kind of measure. Of what?

Have you ever read the criteria for national rankings of US colleges and universities? Stats people would laugh their asses off. Just as an example, “endowments” count heavily. Really? Gold, and others: I would never, never suggest that we should not make Academic success for black athletes, and all black students, a priority, given the data. But do not be foolish about the intervening variables. Gold, there are numerous good points to be made with regard to racially biased behaviors, and you have identified many of them. But honestly I think you need to stop shooting from the hip.
 
You, verbatim.

Me, verbatim.

And again, you threw another hissy fit accusing me of being a racist.

All because you can't handle actually doing research before opening your mouth.

On graduation rates of black athletes....yes per the USC study.
 
What does the graduation rate look like for all students at Iowa? What does the graduation rate look like for all black students at Iowa? ( should look at 5 years of attendance, not 4). Compare football black athletes to all scholarship athletes. Compare ACT’s at Iowa only to schools who have legislative priorities for State residents’ admissions. Compare family income of black athletes to all students, or non-minority students on athletic scholarship. Do longer term follow up studies on whatever measures of success after graduation you may want to use. Explain to me how you define “academics” at Iowa as some kind of measure. Of what?

Have you ever read the criteria for national rankings of US colleges and universities? Stats people would laugh their asses off. Just as an example, “endowments” count heavily. Really? Gold, and others: I would never, never suggest that we should not make Academic success for black athletes, and all black students, a priority, given the data. But do not be foolish about the intervening variables. Gold, there are numerous good points to be made with regard to racially biased behaviors, and you have identified many of them. But honestly I think you need to stop shooting from the hip.

Huck you can twist it however you want. Iowa has issues ...admint it.

Power 5 colleges with lowest graduation rates for black male athletes
  • Louisiana State University (34 percent)
  • University of Georgia (36 percent)
  • University of Florida (37 percent)
  • Oklahoma State University (38 percent)
  • University of California, Berkeley (39 percent)
  • University of Iowa (40 percent)
  • University of Arkansas (40 percent)
  • University of Kentucky (41 percent)
  • Ohio State University (41 percent)
  • University of North Carolina (43 percent)
  • Kansas State University (44 percent)
  • Iowa State University (44 percent)
  • University of Mississippi (45 percent)
upload_2020-6-22_21-5-33.pngupload_2020-6-22_21-6-2.pngupload_2020-6-22_21-6-57.png
 
You are off in the head.
340
 

Damn it Gold, that is exactly why I am critical of many of your posts. You make an outlandish statement like I am twisting my response and denying a problem exists with minority grad rates. For goodness sakes read what I wrote with some comprehension. I asked questions and clearly recognized the problem for minorities. I said Never. Never would I deny there is a problem with grad rates for minorities. I am greatly offended by you spinning or outright misrepresenting what I said.

Where did this data come from? I just did a quick look at UW Madison grad rates. For all students, it was 60.9 % after 6 years. This was from UW itself. Just so you will know, it was reported on numerous occasions to the State School District Administrators that the numbers were closer to 50%. They kind of dropped the data which showed how many did not return after their freshman year. Gave themselves a mulligan, maybe?
 
Damn it Gold, that is exactly why I am critical of many of your posts. You make an outlandish statement like I am twisting my response and denying a problem exists with minority grad rates. For goodness sakes read what I wrote with some comprehension. I asked questions and clearly recognized the problem for minorities. I said Never. Never would I deny there is a problem with grad rates for minorities. I am greatly offended by you spinning or outright misrepresenting what I said.

Where did this data come from? I just did a quick look at UW Madison grad rates. For all students, it was 60.9 % after 6 years. This was from UW itself. Just so you will know, it was reported on numerous occasions to the State School District Administrators that the numbers were closer to 50%. They kind of dropped the data which showed how many did not return after their freshman year. Gave themselves a mulligan, maybe?

Maybe we are of the same mold but bookends like Carr and Livingston.
 
I haven't dug deep into the studies, but I will offer that any study of graduation rates that doesn't control for attrition would be inherently statistically flawed.

Perhaps a more important statistic is the attrition itself, i.e., if Iowa suffers from higher attrition of black athletes, then why is that? That's probably the more important question, and it begs for a deeper analysis.
 
I haven't published this research anywhere. I conducted it out of curiosity along with looking at the leadership committee and attendees at the Big Ten media days in Chicago.

Here's a look at the transfers dating back to the 2009 recruiting class:

Players Listed Arrived at Iowa on Scholarship (source - Rivals.com)


2009 Recruiting Class


Black


Finished Career at Iowa


Micah Hyde

Keenan Davis

Brad Rogers

Jordan Cotton


Left Iowa


Josh Brown


White


Finished Career at Iowa


Nolan MacMillan

Conor Boffeli

Dom Alvis

Brett Van Sloten


Left Iowa


Dakota Getz (injury)

Matt Murphy

Martin Hopkins (injury)

Shane DiBona (injury)

Anthony Schiavone

Scott Covert

Brandon Wegher

Jake Reisen

Drew Clark


2010 Recruiting Class


Black


Finished Career at Iowa


Anthony Hitchens

Kevonte Martin-Manley

Carl Davis

BJ Lowery

Don Shumpert

Christian Kirksey


Left Iowa


Donavan Johnson

De’Andre Johnson (dismissed for legal issues)

Marcus Coker

Anthony Ferguson (quit football)


White


Finished Career at Iowa


Tanner Miller

CJ Fiedorowicz

Andrew Donnal

Mike Hardy

James Morris

Louis Trinca-Pasat


Left Iowa


Jonny Mullings

AJ Derby

Austin Vier (injury)

Jim Poggi (left football)


2011 Class


Black


Finished Career at Iowa (8)


Jordan Canzeri

Darian Cooper

Damon Bullock

Jordan Lomax

Quinton Alston

Jacob Hillyer

Melvin Spears

Jordan Walsh


Left Iowa (6)


Marcus Collins

Mikail McCall

Nico Law

Torrey Campbell (left to run track at Auburn)

John Raymon

Marcus Grant



White


Finished Career at Iowa (7)


John Lowdermilk

Cole Fisher

Riley McMinn

Jake Duzey

Ray Hamilton

Henry Krieger Coole

Austin Blythe


Left Iowa (2)


Dean Tsopanides (graduate transfer)

Jake Rudock (graduate transfer)


2012 Class



Black



Finished career at Iowa (6)



Sean Draper

Tevaun Smith

Anthony Gair

Faith Ekakitie

Greg Mabin

Jaleel Johnson



Left (7)



Barkley Hill

Greg Garmon

Kevin Buford

Ruben Lile

Laron Taylor

Maurice Fleming

Cameron Wilson



White



Finished Career at Iowa (7)



George Kittle

CJ Beathard

Nate Meier

Eric Simmons

Ryan Ward

Drew Ott

Mitch Keppy



Left (4)



Reid Sealby

Cody Sokol (grad transfer)

Daumantas Venckus

Connor Kornbrath (left team, remained on scholarship)



2013 Class



Black


Finished (4)



Akrum Wadley

Desmond King

LeShun Daniels

Damond Powell



Left (8)



Reggie Spearman

Jonathan Parker

Anjeus Jones

Solomon Warfield

Andrew Harris

Derrick Mitchell Jr.

Malik Rucker

Derrick Willies



White


Finished (6)


Josey Jewell

Matt VandeBerg

Jon Wisnieski

Ike Boettger

Sean Welsh

Nathan Bazata


Left (4)


Nic Shimonek

John Kenny

Brant Gressel

Colin Goebel


2014 Class


Black


Finished (2)


Miles Taylor

Josh Jackson


Left (8)


Jalen Embry

Terrence Harris

Jameer Outsey

CJ Hilliard

Omar Truitt

Jay Scheel (injury)

Marcel Joly (left as grad transfer)

Aaron Mends (left as grad transfer)



White


Finished (6)


Ross Reynolds

Dillon Kidd

Parker Hesse

Ben Niemann

Matt Nelson

Keegan Render


Left (3)


Tyler Wiegers (grad transfer)

Mick Ellis

Lucas LeGrand




2015 Class


Black


Finished (2)


Michael Ojemudia

James Daniels


Left (7)


Angelo Garbutt

Eric Graham

Jerminic Smith

Michael Slater

Adrian Falconer

Emmanuel Ogwo (switched to track)

Justin Jinning


White


Finished (7)


Anthony Nelson

Nate Vejvoda

Brady Reiff

Jack Hockaday

Landan Paulsen

Levi Paulsen

Drew Cook



Left (5)


Nick Wilson

Garret Jansen (graduate transfer)

Brett Waechter (health)

Ryan Boyle (grad transfer)

Jake Newborg (quit football)




2016 Class


Black


Finished (6)


Noah Fant

Amani Hooker

Toren Young

Devonte Young

Amani Jones

Cedrick Lattimore



Left (7)


Manny Rugamba

Romeo McKnight

Cedric Boswell

Lance Billings

Brandon Simon

Toks Akinribade (health)

Kyle Taylor (health)


Still in Program (3)


Alaric Jackson

Barrington Wade

Chauncey Golston


White


Finished (3)


Kristian Welch

TJ Hockenson

Nate Stanley


Left (1)


Spencer Williams (health)


Still in Program (4)


Shaun Beyer

Austin Schulte

Nick Niemann

Cole Banwart



2017 Class


Black


Finished (2)


Geno Stone

Tristan Wirfs


Left (4)


Kyshaun Bryan

Trey Creamer

Josh Turner

Camron Harrell


Still in Program (5)


Ihmir Smith-Marsette

Matt Hankins

Brandon Smith

Ivory Kelly-Martin

Djimon Colbert



White


Finished (0)


None


Left (4)


Nate Wieland

Peyton Mansell (grad transfer)

Levi Duwa (left football)

Jacob Coons (left football)



Still in Program (6)


Ryan Gersonde

Henry Marchese

Max Cooper

Mark Kallenberger

Coy Kirkpatrick



*Note - AJ Epenesa, of Polynesian decent, finished.


2018 Class


Black


Still in Program (9)


Kaevon Merriweather

Dallas Craddieth

Calvin Lockett

Julius Brents

Noah Shannon

Terry Roberts

Tyrone Tracy

Mekhi Sargent

Daviyon Nixon


Left (3)


Jayden McDonald

DJ Johnson

Henry Geil


White


Still in Program (9)


Logan Klemp

Nico Ragaini

Seth Benson

Spencer Petras

John Waggoner

Jack Plumb

Cody Ince

Tyler Linderbaum

Riley Moss


Left (3)


Samson Evans

Jeff Jenkins

Dillon Doyle


2019 Class


Ezra Miller (white) is he only player from this class to leave. He dealt with mental health issues and is in transfer portal.
 
fans have the right to disagree with former players, right? how was that an "attack" on MJ? i didn't see any of the tweets, so can you tell me if any of the tweets contained threats against MJ?

Did I Tweet that they were threats?

Yes, you can disagree with former players. And I can say that comments made to him were a bad look. It's my opinion.

He Tweeted the question at me. I answered it. I didn't like his Tweet or Retweet it, just so we're clear.
 
I haven't published this research anywhere. I conducted it out of curiosity along with looking at the leadership committee and attendees at the Big Ten media days in Chicago.

Here's a look at the transfers dating back to the 2009 recruiting class:

Players Listed Arrived at Iowa on Scholarship (source - Rivals.com)


2009 Recruiting Class


Black


Finished Career at Iowa


Micah Hyde

Keenan Davis

Brad Rogers

Jordan Cotton


Left Iowa


Josh Brown


White


Finished Career at Iowa


Nolan MacMillan

Conor Boffeli

Dom Alvis

Brett Van Sloten


Left Iowa


Dakota Getz (injury)

Matt Murphy

Martin Hopkins (injury)

Shane DiBona (injury)

Anthony Schiavone

Scott Covert

Brandon Wegher

Jake Reisen

Drew Clark


2010 Recruiting Class


Black


Finished Career at Iowa


Anthony Hitchens

Kevonte Martin-Manley

Carl Davis

BJ Lowery

Don Shumpert

Christian Kirksey


Left Iowa


Donavan Johnson

De’Andre Johnson (dismissed for legal issues)

Marcus Coker

Anthony Ferguson (quit football)


White


Finished Career at Iowa


Tanner Miller

CJ Fiedorowicz

Andrew Donnal

Mike Hardy

James Morris

Louis Trinca-Pasat


Left Iowa


Jonny Mullings

AJ Derby

Austin Vier (injury)

Jim Poggi (left football)


2011 Class


Black


Finished Career at Iowa (8)


Jordan Canzeri

Darian Cooper

Damon Bullock

Jordan Lomax

Quinton Alston

Jacob Hillyer

Melvin Spears

Jordan Walsh


Left Iowa (6)


Marcus Collins

Mikail McCall

Nico Law

Torrey Campbell (left to run track at Auburn)

John Raymon

Marcus Grant



White


Finished Career at Iowa (7)


John Lowdermilk

Cole Fisher

Riley McMinn

Jake Duzey

Ray Hamilton

Henry Krieger Coole

Austin Blythe


Left Iowa (2)


Dean Tsopanides (graduate transfer)

Jake Rudock (graduate transfer)


2012 Class



Black



Finished career at Iowa (6)



Sean Draper

Tevaun Smith

Anthony Gair

Faith Ekakitie

Greg Mabin

Jaleel Johnson



Left (7)



Barkley Hill

Greg Garmon

Kevin Buford

Ruben Lile

Laron Taylor

Maurice Fleming

Cameron Wilson



White



Finished Career at Iowa (7)



George Kittle

CJ Beathard

Nate Meier

Eric Simmons

Ryan Ward

Drew Ott

Mitch Keppy



Left (4)



Reid Sealby

Cody Sokol (grad transfer)

Daumantas Venckus

Connor Kornbrath (left team, remained on scholarship)



2013 Class



Black


Finished (4)



Akrum Wadley

Desmond King

LeShun Daniels

Damond Powell



Left (8)



Reggie Spearman

Jonathan Parker

Anjeus Jones

Solomon Warfield

Andrew Harris

Derrick Mitchell Jr.

Malik Rucker

Derrick Willies



White


Finished (6)


Josey Jewell

Matt VandeBerg

Jon Wisnieski

Ike Boettger

Sean Welsh

Nathan Bazata


Left (4)


Nic Shimonek

John Kenny

Brant Gressel

Colin Goebel


2014 Class


Black


Finished (2)


Miles Taylor

Josh Jackson


Left (8)


Jalen Embry

Terrence Harris

Jameer Outsey

CJ Hilliard

Omar Truitt

Jay Scheel (injury)

Marcel Joly (left as grad transfer)

Aaron Mends (left as grad transfer)



White


Finished (6)


Ross Reynolds

Dillon Kidd

Parker Hesse

Ben Niemann

Matt Nelson

Keegan Render


Left (3)


Tyler Wiegers (grad transfer)

Mick Ellis

Lucas LeGrand




2015 Class


Black


Finished (2)


Michael Ojemudia

James Daniels


Left (7)


Angelo Garbutt

Eric Graham

Jerminic Smith

Michael Slater

Adrian Falconer

Emmanuel Ogwo (switched to track)

Justin Jinning


White


Finished (7)


Anthony Nelson

Nate Vejvoda

Brady Reiff

Jack Hockaday

Landan Paulsen

Levi Paulsen

Drew Cook



Left (5)


Nick Wilson

Garret Jansen (graduate transfer)

Brett Waechter (health)

Ryan Boyle (grad transfer)

Jake Newborg (quit football)




2016 Class


Black


Finished (6)


Noah Fant

Amani Hooker

Toren Young

Devonte Young

Amani Jones

Cedrick Lattimore



Left (7)


Manny Rugamba

Romeo McKnight

Cedric Boswell

Lance Billings

Brandon Simon

Toks Akinribade (health)

Kyle Taylor (health)


Still in Program (3)


Alaric Jackson

Barrington Wade

Chauncey Golston


White


Finished (3)


Kristian Welch

TJ Hockenson

Nate Stanley


Left (1)


Spencer Williams (health)


Still in Program (4)


Shaun Beyer

Austin Schulte

Nick Niemann

Cole Banwart



2017 Class


Black


Finished (2)


Geno Stone

Tristan Wirfs


Left (4)


Kyshaun Bryan

Trey Creamer

Josh Turner

Camron Harrell


Still in Program (5)


Ihmir Smith-Marsette

Matt Hankins

Brandon Smith

Ivory Kelly-Martin

Djimon Colbert



White


Finished (0)


None


Left (4)


Nate Wieland

Peyton Mansell (grad transfer)

Levi Duwa (left football)

Jacob Coons (left football)



Still in Program (6)


Ryan Gersonde

Henry Marchese

Max Cooper

Mark Kallenberger

Coy Kirkpatrick



*Note - AJ Epenesa, of Polynesian decent, finished.


2018 Class


Black


Still in Program (9)


Kaevon Merriweather

Dallas Craddieth

Calvin Lockett

Julius Brents

Noah Shannon

Terry Roberts

Tyrone Tracy

Mekhi Sargent

Daviyon Nixon


Left (3)


Jayden McDonald

DJ Johnson

Henry Geil


White


Still in Program (9)


Logan Klemp

Nico Ragaini

Seth Benson

Spencer Petras

John Waggoner

Jack Plumb

Cody Ince

Tyler Linderbaum

Riley Moss


Left (3)


Samson Evans

Jeff Jenkins

Dillon Doyle


2019 Class


Ezra Miller (white) is he only player from this class to leave. He dealt with mental health issues and is in transfer portal.

Wow. Now this is a very interesting summary. I want to digest it more carefully, but some years seem to really stick out, one way or another. Thank you, Rob.
 
Wow. Now this is a very interesting summary. I want to digest it more carefully, but some years seem to really stick out, one way or another. Thank you, Rob.
Pretty interesting how many of the departures that were recruited during the GD era were guys that were labelled as WR/RB/ATH.

We had that short stint where we went after smaller, quicker skill players (and if we're being honest, reached for a decent amount of them), compared to the longer, sturdier WRs we've preferred both before and since. One I didn't see was Frank Darby, who requested to be let out of his scholarship after signing with us, and went to ASU, where he's had a pretty nice career.

Also, not saying Rob was wrong to include him, but Lance Billings never made it to campus in the first place. Shame too, because his tape was electric.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top