I'm disappointed in Pavin. Your last guy needs to be a guy that has withstood immense pressure. He had to think that if America was going to win, it would be close and come down to the last match. Put someone in there who has been through it and succeeded. Put Tiger or fill in the 12 spot. You put Phil at 10 anyway so why not go with 12? I love Corey Pavin but he's not the "captain" type IMO.
I see what you are sayign with Pavin, but you almost have to front load the line-up to get back into it. I don't have a problem with Mahan going in the 12 spot. If anyone blew it, it was Stewart Cink, had chances on 17 and 18 to win the match. Plus, all of this is doesn't matter if Fowler doesn't birdie the last 3 to give us a chance.