Poll: SHOULD KIRK RETIRE AT SEASON'S END

Should Kirk retire at season's end?

  • No

    Votes: 19 17.4%
  • Yes

    Votes: 32 29.4%
  • The whole clan should go

    Votes: 58 53.2%

  • Total voters
    109
  • Poll closed .
Hey we agree . . . with the first sentence. I noticed in Rob's thread you said, "Talent isn't the problem." Again, we agree. Those who keep saying "we have less talent" apparently think Iowa has less talent than NDSU & Northwestern. Well, to be fair, they do have one individual with more talent than Iowa's.

You can't bring NDSU into the discussion. Does Iowa have the talent to compete at the D1 Power 5 level. No. My eyeballs tell me there is a big lack of speed and lack of size. There is a lack of gamesmanship from receivers. Iowa is heading to Frank Lauterbur levels. The talent level is worse than when KF got here. It will show once King and Wadley are done and there is not an experienced QB next year. Even counting 2015, look at the battle of the stats. Iowa won a number of games they shouldn't have. Look at the roster and where the players are coming from. Big news was in recruiting when Iowa had 3 potential recruits from Washington as juniors. Washington went 6-3 in Iowa and is a smallish 3A school

This isn't rocket science.

KF has always wanted loyalty in assistants. Except for Norm P, how many assistants coordinators does one really want to have that isn't competitive enough to want to be a head coach.
 
For those who were hoping to be rescued by GB or his replacement. vvvvvv

IOWA CITY — Gary Barta’s office still looks new at Carver-Hawkeye Arena. It’s filled with artifacts and mementos accumulated over his nine years as Iowa’s athletics director.

His office is symbolic of perhaps his proudest moment as the department’s lead officer. On June 12, 2008, with the Cedar and Iowa rivers overflowing throughout the Corridor, Barta persuaded UI President Sally Mason and convinced the Board of Regents to approve a $47 million renovation and construction project to Carver-Hawkeye Arena.

The project was vital toward keeping a self-sustaining athletics department on par with its peers. But it was problematic with the backdrop of a historic flood and a national economic disaster.

“Trying in the midst of those two things to not lose focus, still move forward ... there were days when I sat at my desk and wondered, ‘Just how in the world are we going to do this,’” Barta said. “But Hawkeye fans are great.”

By fall 2011, the basketball and volleyball programs had a much-needed practice facility, coupled with new offices and a face-lift to the arena bowl. That project was one of many completed on Barta’s watch, costing hundreds of millions of dollars. Others include $55 million for a new football practice and operations center, $9 million for a Kinnick Stadium sound and display system and an $8 million boathouse for the rowing program, among others.

By all accounts, this year should rank at the top of Barta’s era as Iowa’s athletics director. Along with the facility boom, his department set records for donations and graduation rates. The women’s basketball team advanced to the Sweet Sixteen and the men won their first NCAA tournament game since 2001. The wrestling squad finished second nationally, men’s gymnastics was sixth, baseball boasted its first NCAA wins since 1972 and the department earned its best Learfield rankings score under Barta.

Yet three areas continuously loom over Barta — football’s stagnation, a Title IX lawsuit filed by four field hockey players and public relations gaffes by his department.

That’s left plenty of speculation about Barta’s future at Iowa. His contract expires June 30, 2016, and his salary was $384,939 in fiscal year 2015. He restructured a deferred compensation account and received a one-time lump sum payment of $417,820 last summer. Barta received strong backing from UI President Sally Mason, whose tenure ends July 31. Opinions about Barta are mixed, both privately and publicly. Through representatives, Mason declined an interview request for this story.

UI alum Bruce Rastetter, a confidant of Gov. Terry Branstad, donated $5 million toward the new football performance center. Rastetter, CEO of The Summit Group and other business ventures, also serves as chairman of the state Board of Regents. Rastetter participates on the UI presidential search committee and ultimately will help select UI’s next president.

When it comes to Barta’s future, Rastetter deferred.

“In regard to Gary, I would let the new president make that decision, the Board of Regents doesn’t,” Rastetter said. “I would assume that the president will sit down with all of those key reports and go through that.

“I think there’s been some positive things with the program. Gary’s been there a long time, he’s a good guy, and we should leave that to the next president.”

Booster Dick Benne, who started the Des Moines I-Club and enters his 49th year as a football season ticket-holder, is impressed with Barta.

“My relationship with him has been very good,” said Benne, who lives in Burlington. “I email him back and forth on a friendship basis once a week, I get an answer back in an hour or two. I think that he listens to what’s going to on in the area.

“He’s a fan’s AD. He’s an excellent speaker and he listens and he gets things done.”
 
I don't see the need for a complete staff overhaul. Our defense has been good enough this year to win most games. It is the offense that is sputtering. There have more injuries on that side of the ball, which have hurt. But I certainly don't think Phil Parker deserves to lose his job. And I think are offensive line coaching has been solid. We are lacking in depth at that position, but that's partially because Greg Davis stole scholarships from the offensive line to recruit wide receivers. This brings up to the main issue. I think its pretty clear that if anyone deserves to be fired its Greg Davis. Even the ESPN announcers were questioning his play calling. I understand that OC is the most hated coach on most teams, and we were all probably too eager to see KOK go. But has Greg Davis does anything at Iowa that inspires confidence?
 
I don't see the need for a complete staff overhaul. Our defense has been good enough this year to win most games. It is the offense that is sputtering. There have more injuries on that side of the ball, which have hurt. But I certainly don't think Phil Parker deserves to lose his job. And I think are offensive line coaching has been solid. We are lacking in depth at that position, but that's partially because Greg Davis stole scholarships from the offensive line to recruit wide receivers. This brings up to the main issue. I think its pretty clear that if anyone deserves to be fired its Greg Davis. Even the ESPN announcers were questioning his play calling. I understand that OC is the most hated coach on most teams, and we were all probably too eager to see KOK go. But has Greg Davis does anything at Iowa that inspires confidence?

Are you just now figuring out GD is a bad fit? Cuz even Jon Miller said in his podcast he figured it out in year 1. And if you can figure it out, and the HC can't, why would you want a HC who is dumber than you???
 
Im still trying to understand the terminology of the playcalling late in the Wisconsin game. Then when I listened to coach Ferentz explain what he was thinking, I was more confused!
 
I think Ferentz might of retired after this year, but the Iowa athletic director decided to sweeten his contract so that he wouldn't go. We can thank the athletic director for his vision in Ferentz staying.
 
I am 100% over Ferentz. I'm ready for new blood even if it means a couple of rebuilding years.
 
I am 100% over Ferentz. I'm ready for new blood even if it means a couple of rebuilding years.
Bring in PJ Fleck.....He would be a good fit and he wants to be here. He took directional Michigan into the top 25 this year. Plus he is only 35 or 36 years old.
 
Ive always been a supporter of coach Ferentz, but IMO I think it might be that time. To be honest, I think its time for a complete staff overhaul. Thoughts?
A few years back I was just about to the level of rooting for losing out to force a change. Now with the extension you can't even do that. It isn't even enjoyable to watch the games anymore....Now that they run off their best offensive recruit (and everyone Eno brought on board will probably leave too). You can't even get excited for what Iowa will have next year anymore. Bring on basketball season already
 
Are you just now figuring out GD is a bad fit? Cuz even Jon Miller said in his podcast he figured it out in year 1. And if you can figure it out, and the HC can't, why would you want a HC who is dumber than you???

Be mad at Gary Barta. Or come up with $30million. The head coach, because of the contract, is too expensive to pressure or fire.

The OC, which is absolutely the fault of Kirk, isnt. I believe everyone who posts here knew Davis was a bad fit before he stepped foot in Iowa, and if they didnt, they knew after 2012.

The new contract made our thoughts on the matter and Kirk's culpability irrelevant.

The only financially responsible changes that can be made currently is the coordinators or assistants.

Noone is just now figuring out Davis is a huge problem (except maybe Kirk, maybe).
 
One yuuuuge unforeseen advantage from 15 years of blazingly bad contract negotiations. Any coach with a decent knowledge of current events and an IQ above plant life knows Iowa is a dream destination school. More proof that the "we'll become Purdue" crowd doesn't understand Iowa's options.
 
I am 100% over Ferentz. I'm ready for new blood even if it means a couple of rebuilding years.

I've posted many times how I've had these inklings beginning in 2006 or 2007. It started off after leaving way too many games with, "WTF?" raised eyebrows. Like many, my loyalty and love for the Hawks caused me to develop enough amnesia during the off-season to renew tix and go through it all again. (Finally broke that cycle after 2014 and have not had a single regret about that, since. I will not even consider buying back in until he's gone.)

Anyone who knows me and has read my posts, knows I've been very consistent in my opinion of Ferentz ...
Never personally met him. Everything I've heard, seen and read convinces me he's a great guy -- good father, loyal husband, a conscientious man of integrity. I could easily see having a beer and conversation with him. At the same time, everything I've read, watched and witnessed convinces me he's, at best, a very average football coach -- very rigid in his schemes, strategies and player management / development, regardless of opponent, situation or players' skill set. This stagnant rigidity is why I started referring to him as, "derKirkFer".

I've been ready and willing for a coaching change since 2010. As Josh and others talk about, I can't accept this mind set by so many that Iowa would become Purdue or Kansas without Kirk Ferentz; that Iowa isn't worthy of attracting a quality coach that could replicate, maybe even exceed, the same level of W's and L's. I just can't wrap my mind around being so convinced it will get worse that the best option is to accept the Hawks consistently under-performing toward 6-6 / 7-5. Don't they want their team to be as competitive and successful as possible? Don't they want their team to win every game they should and always be ready and able to seize opportunities to win the others?

I have no doubt that there are many coaches that could easily coach this team to the 6-6 record it will finish with. I also believe there are plenty of competent coaches who would have coached this team to the 9-3 record it should have finished with.

It's long overdue to find out.
 
I've posted many times how I've had these inklings beginning in 2006 or 2007.

It's long overdue to find out.

Al one really had to do is look at his Maine credentials and his contract negotiations from the start to see this coming. Never have been a fan. Have to admit he hooks me once in a while after years like last year. In my opinion, if you take away King and Wadley (and a few others), this team is no better than and maybe less talented than what KF inherited. The overall team speed wasn't any worse and maybe even not as slow. There weren't Iowa, Nebraska, and SD kids as all over the roster as much as now.
 
Top