Not sure if you are familiar with it, but there is TV network available on DirecTV and possibly other providers that focuses on music called AXS.
They have a program titled, "Vinyl Obsession," in which two music celebrities are brought to a well-known vinyl dealer and are tasked with picking out their top five albums ever (akin to the "on an island" idea). I'm not sure if the show is still active, but I catch reruns occasionally.
I'd have a difficult time narrowing it down to five, but I could probably put together ten.
I decided to put together my 10 just to see how it shook out. Not easy. My criteria was what I'd want with me on a deserted island (favoring a little variety, not just "favorite" albums), and they had to be available on vinyl.
1. Led Zeppelin, "Remasters" 1990
2. Black Sabbath, "Paranoid" 1970
3. Elton John, "Diamonds" 2017
4. ELO, "All Over the World" 1987
5. Fleetwood Mac, "Rumours" 1977
6. Lynyrd Skynyrd,, "Pronounced" 1973
7. Bee Gees, "Greatest" 1979
8. Supertramp, "Breakfast in America" 1979
9. Van Morrison, "Moondance" (Deluxe version) 2023
10. Chris Stapleton, "Traveller" 2015
Can't believe I couldn't squeeze in Pink Floyd, Aerosmith, Doors or Cream...
I cheated a bit with some compilation albums, but, really, how do you choose just one Zeppelin album?