Yes, you set 1st team all conference as your terms, when clearly you can be a difference maker and never make 1st team all conference. Very simple, very strait forward, you're wrong. Heck, if for whatever reason Jok doesn't make 1st team this year, was he not a difference maker?
Second in regards to your 13 & 7 argument, how many players in the Big 10 do you estimate averaged at least 13 & 7 last year? Without putting a ton of effort into looking it up, I believe the number is two (AJ Hammons & Denzel Valentine), Happ was close. I could have missed someone but still these guys aren't exactly a dime a dozen. I'll give you the benefit of the doubt and say there is roughly 20-30 of these guys playing in P5 conferences. You're saying if a recruit doesn't get that or 1st team all conference they cannot be a difference maker... Again you're WRONG!!
This is all coming from a guy who mainly agrees with you in your assessment of Garza as a recruit.