I never said schedules make a team elite. So you think we were elite in 2015? We had a once in a lifetime season which was awesome but I don't think we were elite. An elite team beats Michigan State and hangs with Stanford.
Actually that isn't true at all. Elite teams lose, elite teams play close games. Lets look at Clemson last year, and obvious elite team that won a National Championship.
2016 Clemson
Clemson beat Troy by 6 points last year.
Clemson lost to Pitt who was 8-5 last year, and wasn't even a top 25 team
2016 Clemson played 3 top 25 teams during the year and Championship game, 2015 Iowa played 3 top 25 teams during the year (and Championship game)
Clemson beats #21 Louisville 42-36
Clemson beats #8 Florida St. 37-34
Clemson beats #15 Va Tech in the ACC Championship game 42-35
2015 Iowa
Iowa beats #23 Northwestern 40-10
Iowa beats #21 Wisconsin 10-6
Iowa loses to #6 MSU 13-16
This myth that teams are playing top 25 teams every week is just that a myth. Most teams will play 2-4 top 25 teams a year. Clemson didn't go through some meat grinder to make the Playoffs last year. Iowa didn't lose to an 8-5 team. Iowa only lost to a top 6 team in a very, very close game that could have gone either way. It happens, even elite teams lose close games. Heck an Elite Clemson team lost to an average 8-5 Pitt team.
Was Iowa "Elite" in 2015? IDK, but they were very, very good at the minimum.