PlatypusMessiah
Well-Known Member
CJ Bethard was kind of in a similar circumstance and things turned out ok for him.
Pending background check? Do they want to make sure he has felonies on his record so he fits in?Scotty had his eyes on an upgrade. This guy actually wasn't the first choice, though. A former player turned them down.
In a classic Deuce vs. douche matchup.I just want to see topics like “Iowa drops a Deuce on Nebraska.”
If Hogan doesn't win it this year I don't think you're ever going to see him on that field.
And then the Oliver Martin whack jobs are going to come out of the woodwork and say how we would have won three natties if KF had just gave Doose a shot.
Yeah and if Petras does well early on it's over. It'll be impossible for him to even get a long look and a fair shot. Only so many reps to be had and unless your taking them with the 1st team... Your swimming upstream. Injuries are always the X factor too. We have been really fortunate in that regard with QBs. Stanley was never really hurt during his tenure. Can that luck continue and to what extent?If Hogan doesn't win it this year I don't think you're ever going to see him on that field.
And then the Oliver Martin whack jobs are going to come out of the woodwork and say how we would have won three natties if KF had just gave Doose a shot.
Going to be tough for Deuce to win the job without coming in for the spring. Essentially, he would need to win the job with only fall camp. I am not sure any QB has done that under this head coach.
I have no issue with Hogan at all, I just think there's about a 10% chance he ever sees the field at Iowa. He was born in the wrong year to no fault of his own. Kirk is already leaning Petras, Petras is a known quantity, and Hogan doesn't strike me as a kid who wants to ride the pine for 3 years and play one. He strikes me as someone who thinks he has a greater than 50% chance of being "the guy" when he gets here, but has a rude awakening coming. He's not a journeyman type who's going to grind it out until he's a senior.Yeah and if Petras does well early on it's over. It'll be impossible for him to even get a long look and a fair shot. Only so many reps to be had and unless your taking them with the 1st team... Your swimming upstream. Injuries are always the X factor too. We have been really fortunate in that regard with QBs. Stanley was never really hurt during his tenure. Can that luck continue and to what extent?
Timing is everything. I agree it'll be a matter of how long will he roll the dice to stick it out for? 2 yrs is my over under. I find the odds of him waiting 3 yrs to start 1 to be slim and none.I have no issue with Hogan at all, I just think there's about a 10% chance he ever sees the field at Iowa. He was born in the wrong year to no fault of his own. Kirk is already leaning Petras, Petras is a known quantity, and Hogan doesn't strike me as a kid who wants to ride the pine for 3 years and play one. He strikes me as a guy who thinks he has a greater than 50% chance of being "the guy" when he gets here, but has a rude awakening coming. He's not a journeyman type who's going to grind it out until he's a senior.
Again, I have no beef with the kid at all, but I don't think it's gonna go the way he wants it to.
If Petras is the obvious top guy, he may be Iowa's QB for the next three seasons. That would put Deuce Hogan in the position of red-shirting one season and then sitting on the bench for another two seasons before he can even get on the field. That is a long time to wait. Is he going to want to do that?
Iowa has been extremely fortunate to have 3 straight starters who somehow avoided injuries in CJB, rudock and nate. However that isn’t the norm and regression to the mean is coming. I have to think petras will get injured at some point. We are a bit calloused as Iowa fans, because of extreme QB durability. The backup QB is just one snap away from starting. Look at Tua, Felipe franks etc
I think I've seen somewhere that Deuce has indicated he intends to redshirt.
A tremendous lack of experience at the QB position going into next season would be a major understatement. Hoping for the best. Practice is not the real world when QBs are wearing colors that shout out “don’t hit this guy”.
Now it’s the real world where there is a bullseye on your jersey and eleven guys are on the field all thinking “let’s kill this mother-effer.”
What’s worse is if they are successful and hurt our starting QB and you have backups with zero experience. This all comes back to not getting decent reps for backups by blowing out inferior non-conference foes and letting the backup QB’s get some real game time experience.
Got to give Hayden credit for doing that right.
If Petras struggles and Deuce blows the staff away, it might be sooner than people think that he sees the field. Maybe Deuce is really good, maybe he's not all that, but let's let the staff see him before we declare he's not going to play much.
Come to think of it, let's see how Spencer does when the bullets are flying as well.
A tremendous lack of experience at the QB position going into next season would be a major understatement. Hoping for the best. Practice is not the real world when QBs are wearing colors that shout out “don’t hit this guy”.
Now it’s the real world where there is a bullseye on your jersey and eleven guys are on the field all thinking “let’s kill this mother-effer.”
What’s worse is if they are successful and hurt our starting QB and you have backups with zero experience. This all comes back to not getting decent reps for backups by blowing out inferior non-conference foes and letting the backup QB’s get some real game time experience.
Got to give Hayden credit for doing that right.
If Petras struggles and Deuce blows the staff away, it might be sooner than people think that he sees the field. Maybe Deuce is really good, maybe he's not all that, but let's let the staff see him before we declare he's not going to play much.
Come to think of it, let's see how Spencer does when the bullets are flying as well.
This is going to be a big problem as recruiting becomes more and more important. By saying "you aren't going to play QB at Iowa as a freshman", you're excluding the top QBs in the country from even thinking about listening to a recruiting pitch from you.There's no reason to not redshirt. Unless you are a absolute phenom, or the other QBs all tear their ACLs, you aren't going to play QB at Iowa as a freshman.
If Hogan doesn't win it this year I don't think you're ever going to see him on that field.
And then the Oliver Martin whack jobs are going to come out of the woodwork and say how we would have won three natties if KF had just gave Doose a shot.