So McCall can Redshirt?
- Thread starter HawkPrdatr40
- Start date
iowafincity
Well-Known Member
ok that is your opinion and Im not going to get upset anymore at people who think that.
The reason I think he will not be able to get one is that Kirk said he has been medically cleared and been on record saying he will play since minn.
that would be the 7th game on Iowas schedule he was cleared for. that being said he "was cleared to play" (I say that because that is what kirk said and obviously I do not know that 100%, but I take KFs word for it) so he could have played vs. Minny, Mich, MSU, Purdue, Neb, and the Bowl game...that is 6 games out of 13
In your case you said you missed the past 2 weeks of the season and in indoor track im going to guess that is only 1 or 2 meets, out of how many total meets?
Im guessing that when your cleared to play for nearly half the season like McCalls case, and the coach has said you are "ready to go" for nearly 50 percent of the season, that is a little different than your case where you were out the last meet or maybe last 2.
thats where im coming from hawkize.
Hawkize10000000
Member
I think you misread my post. I compete in the first two meets and didn't compete again that season. Indoor season lasts anywhere from 8-10 weeks, maybe longer depending on how you define it. Usually from the first week of January to the second week of March.
My situation isn't the benchmark for how things are handled, but I think it's a good indicator - regardless of it if you're physically able to get out there later in the year, the injury is what set you back and you didn't - and because of that, I think he'll get a redshirt. Well, I'd almost go as far to say I know he will (if he doesnt take five snaps Saturday like we all know will happen.)
MNHawkeyeFreak
Well-Known Member
Now you're getting it! I think this is the first image in here! Good job!
ForeverHawk
Well-Known Member
I saw this on the ESPN ticker last night regarding Arkansas RB Knile Davis. He broke his ankle in a scrimmage prior to the season. He had surgery. He has been medically cleared and is back practicing. His coaches are debating whether to play him or have him be medically redshirted. Same exact situation as McCall other than McCall had a few carries in one game. Perhaps the Arkansas coaching staff is uninformed just like the Iowa staff? I don't think these situations are ever black n white. I have to think that KF knows what he is doing and a medical redshirt is available if they choose that route. Maybe McCall was cleared to play and there has been a setback in practice or he is not able to go full speed. McCall was cleared earlier in the season compared to Davis, but who knows what has happened since then?
Davis practicing again with Razorbacks | The Slophouse
Davis practicing again with Razorbacks | The Slophouse
Last edited:
boy this gets stranger and stranger with the longer this goes on the HC just said they will try to get a red shirt for McCall,
now if KF thinks he can redshirt there is no reason for this debate to go on, as i feel the HC is in a better position to know what can and will be done
at this point, you clearly want nothing more than to continue to argue
the coaching and medical staff are the only ones that know the true nature of how his recovery is going
personally i find it amazing to think he can compete just 6 weeks after breaking a bone, i don't care how good of shape anyone is in, BONES just don't repair themselves that fast and it takes time to get the soreness and stiffness out of the joints and muscles after a few weeks of inactivety
now if KF thinks he can redshirt there is no reason for this debate to go on, as i feel the HC is in a better position to know what can and will be done
at this point, you clearly want nothing more than to continue to argue
the coaching and medical staff are the only ones that know the true nature of how his recovery is going
personally i find it amazing to think he can compete just 6 weeks after breaking a bone, i don't care how good of shape anyone is in, BONES just don't repair themselves that fast and it takes time to get the soreness and stiffness out of the joints and muscles after a few weeks of inactivety
storminspank
Justin VanLaere
Good stuff. It appears the author of the article is unsure if they will "redshirt" him. The only I read of the coaches in regards to going for the medical hardship waiver was that the OCORD said he doesn't make those decisions.
Gotta love it!
HawkPrdatr40
Well-Known Member
Forever if the Arkansas RB hasn't used his Redshirt than it's simple he can RS, then these situation are very different. McCall's issue is he burned his RS when he played.
Harty: McCall’s medical hardship case not up to him | Hawk Central
Harty: McCall’s medical hardship case not up to him | Hawk Central
Billso
Well-Known Member
Ding ding, we have a winner.
Coker was quoted a week or two ago already as saying he's back to the old McCall as if he never were hurt. I doubt that's gotten any worse. I don't want him sitting if he can help us have a better chance to beat Purdue and Nebraska. Beating Nebraska in Lincoln would be worth it alone and if we won both games we'd be 8-4. Finish successfully and we're more likely to get guys like Smith and Garmon. The question isn't can he redshirt but why redshirt him if he can help us win now?
Billso
Well-Known Member
In your screen name, does the "fin" refer to, like, the fin of a porpoise or walleye or something?
iowafincity
Well-Known Member
In your screen name, does the "fin" refer to, like, the fin of a porpoise or walleye or something?
right on billso!
most people think it means iowa ****in city
HawkPrdatr40
Well-Known Member
KF said on Radio Show lastnight that McCall will play this weekend against Purdue. Says Iowa is looking for wins and McCall can help with that. Aslo stated that McCall would benefit from playing these last 2 weeks. Guess the good ole captain Kirk got more details on the what it will take to get a Hardship waiver approved.
