hogeye
Well-Known Member
Didn't say that, Indy had some solid defenses i don't think any of them were great, the one that won the was the best they had.
I pulled the cheater card because it is a fact...which is why the NFL can down on them with a ton of bricks.
Whatever you mean by "great"...New England or Indy neither one has had a mid-80's Bears caliber defense or an early 2000's Raven's style defense. Those are "great" defenses.
Manning is an overrated QB in my mind. If you want to limit the discussion to regular season, I can concede he's the best over. But in my mind the regular season doesn't define greatness. The post-season does and the regular season stuff is icing on the cake at best.
He's .500 in the post-season. He threw the pick-six that sealed their fate this year. The one SB win he does have is against a team that had a prop for a QB. He's been one and done 6 times in the playoffs.
So, he has some serious ground to make up on guys like Young, Montana and Bradshaw.
There is a lot more football for him to play, so I'll reserve judgment and not get caught up in the moment of the here and now and regular season fantasy football numbers.