I think you all have the right sentiment here, but your theology/philosophy could use some refining.
Philosophically and linguistically, God would not be God if He wasn't in control (through primary and secondary causation) of EVERY little thing in the universe. If He wasn't in control of that ball game and every thing that happened in it, then he would no longer be God.
That said, you guys are right in that God isn't "pulling" for one team or another as we "pull" for our favorite team. God has purposes in doing (or allowing) everything that happened in that bowl game last night, just like he had purposes in doing (or allowing) everything that happened in your home last night.
I can say for certain that everything happens so God will gain more glory in the end of all things. Beyond that, it is hard to declare, from our perspective, what God's purposes are.
And notice that it isn't always good people that have good fortune. Quite often it is the other way around.
So, did Auburn win because God is a big Cam Newton fan or because God wanted to vindicate him and his dad? No way. It is just as likely, from our purview, that God is building Auburn and its coaches/players before a might fall (pride comes before a fall).
Who knows the reason but God? But God was in control, no doubt about it.