Honest question...
As a former OL as well as Oline coach, BF obviously understands the running game and has proven over the last two years that he's very accomplished in that area.
However, our pass blocking has been poor at best and downright awful at worst. In addition, I'm not aware of any experience or skill set he possesses in grooming QBs or in the passing game in general.
Given that, how is BF at all qualified to coordinate the passing portion of the offense?
I'd take David Raih or Joe Philbin over BF. Both have experience at Iowa, they both have a great pedigree, and have been around enough to have picked up a lot of different philosophies and great ideas to incorporate. BF is NOT the answer to fix the passing game.
I quit following Rob on twitter because of takes like this one.
You honestly think Raih has more experience than Brian? Philbin I get, although I don't think he wants to be in college.
He has more experience in passing offense being a former QB as well as tutoring under perhaps the best college QB coach/passing genius in Skippy Neuhisal. Plus, he coaching wide receivers right now in perhaps the most innovative passing offense in the NFL. So yeah, I'd say he has more offensive experience as it relates to the passing game than BF.
No offense Rob!
I'm going to speculate that most
He's the assistant O-Line coach with the Packers.
You're right. I was thinking he was assistant WR coach with the Packers...but my comment still stands!
Brian is the best fit for Kirk and stands the best chance to tweak the head coach's philosophy. KF is here for the foreseeable future. You run the risk of another GD situation if you go that route.
We can agree to disagree. I like Raih and think he'd be a good QB coach. But I think Brian has more experience and is better suited for the position right now.
That's great. He's never called a play, coached a QB or coached a receiver in his life. But yes, let's promote to a Big 10 offensive coordinator job. I can't believe the stupidity I read at times.
I don't think it matters, Kirk Barta is going to hire Brian for the job. Done deal, unfortunately.
We can agree to disagree that Brian is better suited for OC, but I don't think your comment about experience is correct. Raih has coached QBs and TEs at UCLA under Neuheisel, wide receivers at Texas Tech, and the OL at Green Bay under McCarthy. That is over an 8 year period. In addition, his story is pretty cool and fits in pretty well with Iowa's culture...
Rob, you mentioned AJ Blazek as OL coach. Do you think Brian would be OC/OL coach? The past coordinators have coached positions. Just curious.
Also, Chad Leistikow mentioned a possible 10th assistant coach for D1 schools, but didn't say anything about whether or not it was happening this year. Do you know if it is coming next fall?
I could go along with this. Young guy like Brian isn't going to want shatty offense after shatty offense, it would kill his future in the ranks.Bingo... I don't think it could be more of a no brainer either. Bringing Philbin in or someone like that to playcate to Kirk would very likely be Greg Davis 2.0 Brian can stand up to his Dad in ways outsiders can't or at least wouldn't. Brian clearly is opinionated, aggressive and wants to do well. He doesn't want to have the 120 something worse passing offense. He'll be aggressive in recruiting and everything. He'd be the jolt the program needs