lick got in pretty late on gibbs...alford recruited him mainly.
IIRC, gibbs loved mcdermott.
Gibbs was maybe a 1/2 inch to inch taller than Gatens but he was a really long player kind of like Jake Kelly.
I would say Gibbs was a tad better athlete than Gatens in terms of his first step and jumping ability. Gatens was physically stronger than Gibbs though.
Gibbs might be better off at an MVC school. I don't know how he has developed the past couple years strength wise and basketball ability wise.
I think he had the body/potential to be a solid role player in the Big 10/Big 12. I don't know what he really offers now.
I saw him get some decent minutes in the game in which the Zags had their very long unbeaten string in conference games broken. It was a multiple-OT affair and one of the bext college hoops games I saw all season.
Gibbs is only a soph and has struggled with injuries, but I didn't see anything in that game (in which he appeared to be fully healthy) that would make him particularly exciting to me as a possible transfer. He played hard but not exceptionally well.
Freddy:
I saw the same game and like you I was not impressed. However, he had a serious leg injury his freshman year and it now appears to me he has lost some of the athleticism he demonstrated in high school.