I'm with you KC. I like both Fran and Davis. I think they've actually had remarkably similar tenures. If you remove the first 2 or 3 years for each (which you could argue they weren't completely responsible for), I think it is really difficult to figure out who was better.
Fran gets credit for guys like the Murrays, but Davis deserves just as much praise for identifying players like Ryan Bowen.
Something that gets overlooked, too...Iowa high school basketball is SO much better now than when Davis was coach. It sucks we lost elite players to Kansas, but we're talking KANSAS basketball in the 1990s.
Davis had some pretty high profile pulls with Ray Thompson, Acie Earl, Kingsbury, Kenyon Murray, Street, Russ Millard, Settles, Ricky Davis, Dean Oliver etc....he didn't win every recruiting battle but it's revisionist history to say Iowa didn't get players under him. I think people also forget the big time transfers who were attracted to his style. Matt Bullard, Andre Woolridge, Sam Okey...