If Tucker screwed up again and got a third alcohol related arrest, I don't think that would cost Lick his job. There is a reason there are guidelines set up by the university, so the decision doesn't and can't rest solely on the coach.
Tucker drank, Tucker unfortunately got caught this time in what was an unlucky situation. Tucker needed to be more careful because he had trouble before. I have no inside information, but I doubt Tucker is the only Hawk basketball player to drink during the season!
Additionally, it seems that the same people who are not happy with Lick don't want Tucker back and want to blame it on Lick for allowing Tucker back???
I'm not saying that Tucker screwing up again would cost Lick his job directly. However, we need players in this program next season. Many people, including people who have no axe to grind with Lickliter, believe he has to do something by next year to save his job. If Tucker occupies a scholarship through next season but ends up not being able to play, that's a ride that could have been used by someone who might contribute. For example, we desperately need a PG and at the moment don't have a scholarship to give for next season. That's the opportunity cost of taking Tucker back if he screws up again.
It's an independent issue (relative to whether Tucker
should come back), but I also think we'd be better off on the court if we used his ride for a good juco PG. Perhaps another ride will become available, but there aren't many positive scenarios by which that could occur.
You want to draw a connection between "not wanting Tucker back" and not being "happy" with Lickliter. Do you know
anyone who's really
"happy" with Lickliter at this point?
I don't. I know people who have varying degrees of concern, from "mild concern tinged with optimism" to the premature "let's get rid of him now" crowd. Most of us are somewhere in between. The Tucker issue has not made me feel any better about Lickliter, but the issues of whether AT comes back and whether Lickliter is the coach of the future at Iowa are independent, except perhaps in the event Tucker does screw up again and leaves us (again) with a short roster.
As for me, I came into this season the eternal optimist as I usually do, but have been stunned at how poorly Iowa has played for most of the season thus far. As a result I'm becoming very concerned about whether we have the right coach or not. The fact that we have no quickness whatsoever in our backcourt is a very serious shortcoming and it's cause for serious concern about Lick's recruiting judgment. I like the incoming class but would feel much better about the chances for turning this thing around next season if we added a guard with superior quickness.