No idea. CHris didn't do anything illegal and I doubt there are any rules that were broken....its the media room, and ultimately Kirk Ferentz should know better than to say things like that in a room filled with 10 or more reporters. It just comes down to what people feel is fair, and there are a lot of opinions on that matter, none being absolute right or wrong.
I kind of disagree, Jon, with your last sentence above. I believe there are some that are completely wrong.
When you ask someone to logically explain the thought process behind this sort of thing you might get an answer similar to Tork. When this guy that evidently writes for the DI explains it from a reporter's perspective, then everyone on here seems to listen to him and agree.
But if someone explains why they think it is an unfair question (while staying away from the should the camera have been on or not line of thought) you will get an answer that basically is something like, "That guy that I like so much shouldn't have to put up with that gotcha question." I believe that type of answer (and there are other types of answers similar to this that aren't based in logic) is absolutely wrong.
By the way, just because someone has a bad answer or looks bad when they answer a question, that doesn't make it a gotcha question. What makes it a gotcha question many times is when someone is unprepared or too stupid to properly answer a question. Then their defense is that it was an unfair or gotcha question. Then all of their peeps parrot those same comments and they all attempt to blame the reporter for just asking a reasonable question.
There are absolutely, positively a LOT of people who come here and other places who have no idea what the media does or what they are supposed to do. You see it when you hear people wine about how a columnist that has a job to editorialize isn't doing his or her job when they don't give equal time to both sides of a story. That obviously isn't the job of a columnist, whereas it probably is the duty of the beat writer, or in the news department a writer who is writing a story.
I will tell you one thing, and that is that the media had better do its job on this story. Our university is acting like Penn State when they clam up on something like this. If they want people like me and my friends to send our children to their school, then they damn well better not re-hire people that appear to have had these sorts of problems when they were around the first time. I personally would not blame anyone for hiring this guy the first time if they had no way of knowing he had the issues he seems maybe to have had. But when you let a guy leave a job without firing him or properly tracking his inappropriate actions when he was here, then you let him get hired somewhere else or worse yet (if that is possible in this context) rehired at Iowa, then you have not done something that is not just your job but your moral obligation.
Think about this. If he is guilty of the things that are being said and they just let him go, they would have possibly let him go and he might go on to do the sorts of things Sandusky did and the administration at Iowa, by not doing their job properly, would have had a hand in enabling him. How does that sit with you?
The media doing their job keeps things like that from happening, whether you care to admit it or not. And I better get some good answers as to what went on here or I will be writing letters to the Sports Editor of the Register and to the Board of Regents and to President Mason. I might even attempt to make it to an event that Mason or Barta is at and ask them a question in public just to get under their skin and to get them to understand that if they don't want to be transparent then they are going to have to be uncomfortable doing it.
I said this when the Penn State story broke and I will say it now. Our school is only as good as the people that we hire to run it. At Penn State they hired some people that appear to have at bare minimum looked the other way and at the worst covered up for serial rapist and child abuser and allowed him to perpetrate his crimes for years.
We had all better hope that our school hired people that, for whatever reason, show better leadership and judgement. If they haven't or don't we may very well find ourselves feeling like a PSU fan in more ways than one.