OK State or Alabama

Who should play?

  • OSU

    Votes: 25 83.3%

  • Bama

    Votes: 5 16.7%
  • Total voters
    30
hawkfan340 said:
LSU wins by 25+ if there's a rematch. They're far better than Alabama and not playing on Bama's turf.
Click to expand...

Disagree. LSU might win but they are not blowing out Alabama. Jordan Jefferson sucks and LSU's offense would be lucky to score a touchdown let alone multiple. It would be pretty hard to win by 25 if you can't score 25. Unless they have multiple scores off turnovers and kick returns, they're not scoring 25+.

Only one team scored more than 14 points against Alabama. Georgia Southern scored 21 and I'm guessing that's because Alabama didn't really care about that game. They would have won with third stringers.
 
Too many other playmakers on LSU. All they need to do is not have their QB turn it over. They were still playing their even worse QB when they played Alabama the first time.

Maybe you're right though, and we'd instead see the most one-side 17-0 beatdown of all time.
 
Wins against current top 25:

Oklahoma St.: 5
Alabama: 2


Wins against bowl bound teams:

Oklahoma St.: 7
Alabama: 3
 
DwayneTwill said:
Terrible losses:

OSU: 1
Alabama: 0
Click to expand...

Bama quality wins: Penn state, Arkansas, Auburn

- only three wins over teams with a record above .500, didnt win conference, loss was at home

OSU quality wins: Texas, Oklahoma, K-state, Baylor, Mizzou (doesnt include two other's headed for a bowl @ .500)

-won conference, loss was the on road in double OT

Bama also didnt have to play two of the toughest teams in the conference (South Carolina and georgia). OSU played errbody in theirs
 
howdydodat said:
Hopefully Oklahoma State but for everyone knocking Alabama, they won every game by three scores. Just something to think about while you're throwing them under the bus for not playing the greatest schedule in the world. It's not like anyone was even remotely close to beating them aside from LSU who couldn't beat them in regulation.

Also, Alabama was the only team to beat Penn State prior to Paterno(8-1) being fired. Penn State may have finished 1-2(9-3) regardless but they were the only ones to beat Paterno.

So... I'm hoping for Oklahoma State but I believe Alabama is the better team and probably more deserving.

+16 @Penn State
+17 @Miss State
+28 @Auburn
+28 @Florida
+45 @Ole Miss

-3 LSU(OT)
+24 Georgia Southern
+24 Arkansas
+31 Tennessee
+34 Vanderbilt
+41 Kent State
+41 North Texas

That's 9 wins by four scores or more.
Click to expand...

OSU
+27 La Laf.
+23 AZ
+26 @Tulsa
+1 @A&M
+42 Kansas
+12 @Tex
+21 @Mizzou
+35 Baylor
+7 KSU
+60 @TT
-6 @ISU
+34 OK

You know what this proves? Nothing because Bama already lost to LSU on their own field. Why do they deserve another chance on a neutral site?

If I was an LSU player I would be pi$$ed to have to play Bama again after already beating them in their house.
 
hawkfan340 said:
Wasn't a terrible loss.
Click to expand...

Agreed. As much as it may pain some of us to say it, ISU is a decent team this year, and they played the game of their entire program, and OSU had a lot of off the field stuff to deal with that day.
 
OK State vs LSU
Alabama vs Stanford

These are two BCS games I would watch. I will not watch LSU vs bama a second time. *yawwwn*
 
theboat said:
Agreed. As much as it may pain some of us to say it, ISU is a decent team this year, and they played the game of their entire program, and OSU had a lot of off the field stuff to deal with that day.
Click to expand...

Whoops! Those two years in ames are showing through again, boat. :rolleyes:
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Share this page

Top