Recruiting momentum: Top 5 class in 2000 with Top 35 recruits Reiner and Worley,plus Luke and Reggie Evans.
2001: Two top 50 recruits in Pierce and Sommerville
2002: Two top 60 recruits in Horner and Brunner.
Loss of momentum:
2003: Mike Henderson,Adam Haluska
2004: Carlton Reed,Alex Thompson
SA had it going his first 3 years,but Luke breaking his knee, and the following year when Luke was still hurting...then PP incident, ect...it started falling apart.
My point exactly, you listed 4 players that didn't make it through the Iowa program and you left out Sonderliter. Sommerville never played a game for the Hawks. Horner and Brunner were two I listed that did actually play all four years. Haluska was a transfer, I think he would have been a Hawk if we had the scholarship available.
I don't think Luke breaking his knee had that big of an impact on recruiting. Iowa did win another Big Ten tournament and then Iowa had Reed and Thompson transfer off that team, I believe.
The Iowa program degraded with the type of players Alford recruited. There were so many that he signed that didn't qualify. Hansen, Looby were guys that had positive impacts on Iowa, but I believe there were academic issues with Hansen in the beginning, which was why he went to JUCO and Looby was not ready for the Big Ten, but he contributed nicely in his two years.
The montra that surrounded Alford, his agrrogance, or seemingly arrogance is what left a sour taste with people. Being at the B10 tournament the last time they won, it didn't seem like there was much team unity during the celebration. Some players didn't even talk to one another the whole celebration. It was really weird and I do think that was evident from people looking at it.
The only real difference between Alford and Lickliter was Alford won, but with zero integrity.
Players that Alford signed and didn't finish or get to campus at Iowa:
Josh Rhoades, Nick DeWitz, Tony Freeman, Nathan Skinner, Josh Crawford, Tyler Smith, Jamie Vanderbeeken, Alex Thompson, Carlton Reed, Pierre Pierce, Marcus Sommerville, Sean Sonderliter, Sam Okey and David Palmer...there may be others that I am missing. We as fans had a problem with Lickliter and the players transferring, but it wasn't much better with SA. Add in the transfers, which I don't have a problem with in general, think about how the roster turned over like it did. There was a nice transition from Recker/Evans to Horner/Brunner group, but don't think Iowa wasn't hurt after the knee injury to Recker for recruiting. 14 players I can think of off the top of my head that did not make it to campus or play 4 years for Iowa, not counting JUCO and transfers, that is sad.