I think people are too hung up on how players are ranked and who else offered. I think we'd all agree we'd like to have a few of Butlers players on our team. Here is how Scout ranked the Butler players before committing...
Shelvin Mack: 2 star - offers from Butler, Bradley, UAB and Miami
Ronald Nored: 2 star - offers from Butler, Harvard, S Alabama, W Kentucky, Wright St
Gordon Heyward: 2 star - just list Butler but had a couple major offers
Matt Howard: 3 star - Mostly mid majors but a couple major offers
My point is don't get too hung up on how services like Scout have them ranked. Would you have thought a team made up of the above would have been playing for the national championship? Kirk has proven it works in football and it can work in basketball, too. Just because we don't land the blue-chippers doesn't mean we aren't getting talented players.