McNutt I'm not sure about. He's an EXCELLENT "lead by example" guy, but he doesn't seem to be very vocal. Seems like a REALLY quiet guy. That worked for Brad Banks, but Banks was also playing QB and made the offense tick.
Don't get me wrong, we need to have guys like that on the team. But I think we need to have more vocal leaders as captains. We didn't seem to have that this year.