Fantasy Football trade proposal... would ya?

ibahawkeye

ibahawkeye

Well-Known Member
I have Michael Turner and I'm being offered Roddy White.

We start 3 RB & 3 WR in our league and here is what I have at these positions:

RB
M. Lynch
D. Murray
R. Matthews
M. Turner
D. Brown
D. Thomas

WR
M. Colston
J. Nelson
M. Floyd
D. Amendola
S. Rice
A. Hawkins
A. Roberts

This past week I didn't even start Turner and neither Colston or Nelson have caught a TD pass this year. I do value depth at the RB position and I like having the posibility to play against possible matchups. Both Brown and Thomas scored 10 + points this week.

Just not sure if I should pull the trigger... what u say?

edit: right now I'm 3-0 in the league so fine with record but looking to strengthen roster for playoffs.
 
YES. I tried to make the reverse trade so I would get White. they wouldn't go for it, I'd definitely take that deal.
 
Got another trade proposal for you guys...Alfred Morris for Hakeem Nicks. I'm giving Morris and getting Nicks, at RB I'll still have Richardson, Gore, Mathews, Sproles and J Stewart. I'm weak at WR with Steve Smith, D Bowe and Denarius Moore. If Nicks was healthy it wouldn't even be a question but he's out with a knee injury and information is lacking on when he will be back. Also, Morris is looking less and less like a fluke each week and Mathews has been disappointing even with coming off an injury. I'm probably going to pull the trigger but what say you?
 
Yes in a heart beat I would make that trade. That is i would make both those trades and never look back.
 
Make both trades!

Edit: Here's my possible trade scenario, I would give Eli and Megatron for RG3 and AJ Green. Should I?
 
I hate my leagues. Trades never happen. People always want to get "the better end of the deal", they don't understand fair trade value. Even if they need an RB they won't trade an equally valued receiver for it...they want an RB1 for a WR2. Pisses me off.
 
Super - yeah I'd make that trade but I'd want a solid back up QB on my bench in case RG3 goes down.
Cliche - same problem in my leagues, its frustrating to say the least
 
clicheusername3 said:
I hate my leagues. Trades never happen. People always want to get "the better end of the deal", they don't understand fair trade value. Even if they need an RB they won't trade an equally valued receiver for it...they want an RB1 for a WR2. Pisses me off.
Click to expand...

This is exactly how my leagues work as well. It annoys the bejesus out of me.
 
superfan12 said:
Make both trades!

Edit: Here's my possible trade scenario, I would give Eli and Megatron for RG3 and AJ Green. Should I?
Click to expand...

Personally, I would not make that trade. Megatron will put up some numbers. I had him last year so I am a little biased there. I don't think RG3 will continue to put up the numbers he has for the rest of the year. Although AJ Green is solid. Eli is tough. He could put up 30-40 fantasy points one week and then 10 the next, no real consistency from a fantasy standpoint. Although he is one heck of a QB and a winner.
 
Cosity82 said:
Super - yeah I'd make that trade but I'd want a solid back up QB on my bench in case RG3 goes down.
Cliche - same problem in my leagues, its frustrating to say the least
Click to expand...

Igothawked said:
Personally, I would not make that trade. Megatron will put up some numbers. I had him last year so I am a little biased there. I don't think RG3 will continue to put up the numbers he has for the rest of the year. Although AJ Green is solid. Eli is tough. He could put up 30-40 fantasy points one week and then 10 the next, no real consistency from a fantasy standpoint. Although he is one heck of a QB and a winner.
Click to expand...

If I were to make the trade I'd have RG3 and my backup would be Andrew Luck, RG3's bye week is week 10, Luck plays Jacksonville that week so I feel somewhat comfortable about that. I just don't want to give up on Megatron.
 
ibahawkeye said:
I have Michael Turner and I'm being offered Roddy White.

We start 3 RB & 3 WR in our league and here is what I have at these positions:

RB
M. Lynch
D. Murray
R. Matthews
M. Turner
D. Brown
D. Thomas

WR
M. Colston
J. Nelson
M. Floyd
D. Amendola
S. Rice
A. Hawkins
A. Roberts

This past week I didn't even start Turner and neither Colston or Nelson have caught a TD pass this year. I do value depth at the RB position and I like having the posibility to play against possible matchups. Both Brown and Thomas scored 10 + points this week.

Just not sure if I should pull the trigger... what u say?

edit: right now I'm 3-0 in the league so fine with record but looking to strengthen roster for playoffs.
Click to expand...

no
 
here's a trade sent to me i think its a no brainer to take it but with Gore always having issues and hunter and few others the 49ers put in back field and with welker im worried when hernandez comes back he will lose value. Thoughts?

I GET
Welker
Gore

I GIVE
McCoy
Bryant

Currently Have in a NON-PPR league
QB- Peyton Manning and Vick
RB- LeSean Mccoy, Chris Johnson, Darren McFadden, Shonn Greene
WR- Roddy White, Percy Harvin, Amendola, Colston, Hawkins, Dez Bryant
 
pin2win said:
here's a trade sent to me i think its a no brainer to take it but with Gore always having issues and hunter and few others the 49ers put in back field and with welker im worried when hernandez comes back he will lose value. Thoughts?

I GET
Welker
Gore

I GIVE
McCoy
Bryant

Currently Have in a NON-PPR league
QB- Peyton Manning and Vick
RB- LeSean Mccoy, Chris Johnson, Darren McFadden, Shonn Greene
WR- Roddy White, Percy Harvin, Amendola, Colston, Hawkins, Dez Bryant
Click to expand...

No... I'm not sure I would give LeSean up for much of anything but definetly not enough with Welker and Gore.
 
ibahawkeye said:
I have Michael Turner and I'm being offered Roddy White.

We start 3 RB & 3 WR in our league and here is what I have at these positions:

RB
M. Lynch
D. Murray
R. Matthews
M. Turner
D. Brown
D. Thomas

WR
M. Colston
J. Nelson
M. Floyd
D. Amendola
S. Rice
A. Hawkins
A. Roberts

This past week I didn't even start Turner and neither Colston or Nelson have caught a TD pass this year. I do value depth at the RB position and I like having the posibility to play against possible matchups. Both Brown and Thomas scored 10 + points this week.

Just not sure if I should pull the trigger... what u say?

edit: right now I'm 3-0 in the league so fine with record but looking to strengthen roster for playoffs.
Click to expand...

For the record... I ended up not making this trade. And I'm kinda glad. Roddy had a huge week but Matthews hasn't done much. Bye weeks are starting for my RB starting this week so I'll need a 4th RB for a complete roster at the RB spot during the bye weeks.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Share this page

Top