College Football playoff is a Joke

[docholihawk]

Just to put the level of stupidity into context. Yesterday Danny Kannel said if Florida beats Clemson, Florida would deserve to be in the playoff before Iowa. Isn't the Government required to help people this challenged.

 

[deanvogs]

Just to put the level of stupidity into context. Yesterday Danny Kannel said if Florida beats Clemson, Florida would deserve to be in the playoff before Iowa. Isn't the Government required to help people this challenged.

If Florida beats Bama, and the SEC is left out of the playoffs, the South would try secession again.

 

[deanvogs]

We will see if this is actually legit or not today. If it is legit it should look like this:

1) Clemson
2) Michigan St.
3) Alabama
4) Oklahoma
5) Iowa/Stanford
6) Stanford/Iowa
7) Ohio St.


I don't see how you could possible put Bama ahead of MSU. Michigan St. has beaten 2 top 10 teams, and 4 top 16 teams. 'Bama's best win is Ole Miss which is barely better than MSU 4th best win.

I also don't see how you can rank OSU ahead of Iowa when they both have about the same "best win" (#14 jNW on the road vs #15 Michigan on the road) Both lost to a top 4 MSU in a similar close fashion. The rest of the resume isn't close as Iowa has wins over the next best teams played in Wisconsin on the road, Pitt, and has an overall SOS tougher than OSU. Plus Iowa won it's division ahd 1 more win than OSU and went undefeated in the regular season. All things OSU could do.

As far as resumes go, the committee has almost perfect comparisons, and OSU doesn't beat Iowa in any criteria at all......except the name on the front of the Jersey.

 

[PCHawk]

We will see if this is actually legit or not today. If it is legit it should look like this:

1) Clemson
2) Michigan St.
3) Alabama
4) Oklahoma
5) Iowa/Stanford
6) Stanford/Iowa
7) Ohio St.


I don't see how you could possible put Bama ahead of MSU. Michigan St. has beaten 2 top 10 teams, and 4 top 16 teams. 'Bama's best win is Ole Miss which is barely better than MSU 4th best win.

I also don't see how you can rank OSU ahead of Iowa when they both have about the same "best win" (#14 jNW on the road vs #15 Michigan on the road) Both lost to a top 4 MSU in a similar close fashion. The rest of the resume isn't close as Iowa has wins over the next best teams played in Wisconsin on the road, Pitt, and has an overall SOS tougher than OSU. Plus Iowa won it's division ahd 1 more win than OSU and went undefeated in the regular season. All things OSU could do.

As far as resumes go, the committee has almost perfect comparisons, and OSU doesn't beat Iowa in any criteria at all......except the name on the front of the Jersey.

All true but Alabama's best win.