Can we put this narrative to rest. One last time, this is Kirk's livelihood. He coaches to win, not to give the fans and state the finger. Do you think he has time when game planning for the next opponent or when Brian goes through the play sheet to stop and think "OK, let's see how I can give the fans the finger this time?" If the boosters have his back, as opposed to Chryst at Wisconsin, then good for him for having the instincts and foresight to see where the bread is buttered.
In a post millennial world where people demand change at the first sign of adversity, Kirk stands out like a dinosaur. This, along with his smugness and control of local media, is what really gets under people's skin.
If you don't like it, don't attend, don't watch, and dont post. Or if you post at least change the narrative. There are more legit issues to criticize Kirk on than this one.
Few are expecting the offense to take a jumpI'm a little baffled why there's so much optimism about Iowa's offense next year.
There are certainly no difference-makers arriving to bail out the O-line, and we saw little to no progress from that group over the course of last year, even tho by the end of the season many of the 1st-time starters had 13 games under their belts. Why would we expect anything different during games 14-16?
We lost one of our two best WRs, with no new WRs arriving expected to make a difference.
We lost the #2 and #3 RBs -- granted, probably not that hard to replace, but still.
We lost our best TE. Yes, a couple decent ones return, but none an All-American like the departed.
Does anyone think QB McNamara, coming off major knee surgery, is going to be especially mobile? I don't.
At best, I see largely a replay of the 2022 season.
I am baffled by our failure to utilize the portal to shore up obvious weak spots in critical positions.I'm a little baffled why there's so much optimism about Iowa's offense next year.
There are certainly no difference-makers arriving to bail out the O-line, and we saw little to no progress from that group over the course of last year, even tho by the end of the season many of the 1st-time starters had 13 games under their belts. Why would we expect anything different during games 14-16?
We lost one of our two best WRs, with no new WRs arriving expected to make a difference.
We lost the #2 and #3 RBs -- granted, probably not that hard to replace, but still.
We lost our best TE. Yes, a couple decent ones return, but none an All-American like the departed.
Does anyone think QB McNamara, coming off major knee surgery, is going to be especially mobile? I don't.
At best, I see largely a replay of the 2022 season.
Regarding the O Line, I think this nails it. We are going to have to see improvement from the returning pieces and have some contributions from the portal additions. If we get even average O Line play it makes us a lot better offense. What I would like to see at a minimum is some consistency. Will that happen? That's the $64 question.Honestly the biggest problem is the offensive line. No quarterback, wide receiver or coach is going to make a difference until the offensive line improves exponentially. The current staff (Brian and Kirk) should be able to fix that. That being said the offensive line has been bad for awhile now and they haven’t found any answers. Fix the offensive line and you can make the offense average. Make the offense average and you have a shot at competing for a national championship. It’s a long shot but it’s a shot. We will most likely miss Jack. Not sure how you replace someone like him. Every other position ( offense and defense) we should have equal or better players available.
The narrative that he would put mediocre product on the field or on the staff just to stick it to the fans is so asinine to assume that I will double down, triple down, even meet you personally to discuss it.First of all I've spent a good amount of money on Iowa Football whether it be season tickets, tailgating Iowa gear.
Second of all I'll post when or what ever the hell I want.
Apparently any opinion that isn't your's, you feel the need to inflict yours. I guess if there is a post that annoys you skip it and go to the next that gives you the warm fuzzies. And yes it's Kirks smug in your face type attitude that my post was meant for. I've given plenty respect and at a boy's to KF over the years but BF staying in place when all you would of needed is a top 100 offense the last couple years with the special teams and defense Iowa has had to have something special compared to the mediocre display that has been on the field is a direct reflection on him. If fans want to point to poor o-line performance, or telegraphed plays that never work and poor QB play that is also on the captain. I'm realistic enough to know Iowa's never going to win a NC but not ignorant enough to believe we shouldn't be competing for big w titles. Where do you think the program will be when USC and UCLA get here. Are you really that naive to believe we're going to compete with the mentality Kirk is displaying?
I am baffled by our failure to utilize the portal to shore up obvious weak spots in critical positions.
WR: Iowa lost two starting 4* WR's who transferred out to P5 schools. There are over 100 4* and 3* WR's in the 2023 portal. From this pool of available transfer talent, many of whom are still uncommitted, Iowa brought in one FCS WR (who has no star rating) as the "replacement".
OL: Iowa had possibly the worst OL in the B10 last year. Again, dozens of P5 OL in the transfer portal. We brought in one DII OL and one MAC OL.
Pretty weak showing by a B10 program. Not going to be enough to move the dial, in my opinion.
Knew it! You'd reply! To easy! I'm entitled to have know one kiss my ass nor will I ever kiss anyone's either. But you couldn't see the light anyway because your head is so far kirks ass because your an apologist for him. Part of the Ferentz pr dept I'm guessing. Hell could be BF himself. Please reply because it's a given and I definitely like fishing. Especially when they are biting. And far as Kirk putting a mediocre product on the field because of his my way system... Damn fucking right he does. Proofs in results and his decision to stay with his son as OC. If fucking Barta would have had nuts we wouldn't be even having the conversation because BF wouldn't have been hired for the position no matter what conflict of interest bullshit they say doesn't exist.The narrative that he would put mediocre product on the field or on the staff just to stick it to the fans is so asinine to assume that I will double down, triple down, even meet you personally to discuss it.
It's BULLSHIT, and so is your take.
Have you ever thought that sometimes we lose or look mediocre because the other team or other coaches are simply better?
Or do you think your place as a paying supporter entitles Kirk to kiss your ass?
Think about it.
One. More. Time. (Let me go slowly so you can follow along)Knew it! You'd reply! To easy! I'm entitled to have know one kiss my ass nor will I ever kiss anyone's either. But you couldn't see the light anyway because your head is so far kirks ass because your an apologist for him. Part of the Ferentz pr dept I'm guessing. Hell could be BF himself. Please reply because it's a given and I definitely like fishing. Especially when they are biting. And far as Kirk putting a mediocre product on the field because of his my way system... Damn fucking right he does. Proofs in results and his decision to stay with his son as OC. If fucking Barta would have had nuts we wouldn't be even having the conversation because BF wouldn't have been hired for the position no matter what conflict of interest bullshit they say doesn't exist.
Wow. I'd agree except how close Iowa has been to putting it together. The few missing pieces are typically so bad it doesn't make sense. Until now.The narrative that he would put mediocre product on the field or on the staff just to stick it to the fans is so asinine to assume that I will double down, triple down, even meet you personally to discuss it.
It's BULLSHIT, and so is your take.
Have you ever thought that sometimes we lose or look mediocre because the other team or other coaches are simply better?
Or do you think your place as a paying supporter entitles Kirk to kiss your ass?
Think about it.
Everyone knows that Brian led offenses are near the bottom in yardage.Wow. I'd agree except how close Iowa has been to putting it together. The few missing pieces are typically so bad it doesn't make sense. Until now.
Yes and one year it was an incredibly bad punter. Several years it was the qb with a better one on the bench.Everyone knows that Brian led offenses are near the bottom in yardage.
That's because our defense and special teams frequently give them offense short fields as much as anything else.
It you were to go by points (and I don't care how they're scored) we are usually closer ro the middle of the pack.
What the detractors don't pay attention to is the statistics that probably aren't even kept track of, but win us games.
For example, how much yardage do we gain on exchanges of punts?
That stuff counts and it wins us games.
Well... When you put it like that.I am baffled by our failure to utilize the portal to shore up obvious weak spots in critical positions.
WR: Iowa lost two starting 4* WR's who transferred out to P5 schools. There are over 100 4* and 3* WR's in the 2023 portal. From this pool of available transfer talent, many of whom are still uncommitted, Iowa brought in one FCS WR (who has no star rating) as the "replacement".
OL: Iowa had possibly the worst OL in the B10 last year. Again, dozens of P5 OL in the transfer portal. We brought in one DII OL and one MAC OL.
Pretty weak showing by a B10 program. Not going to be enough to move the dial, in my opinion.