Best of the B1G: Wide Receivers

JonDMiller

Publisher/Founder
We continue our look at 'The Best in the Big Ten' series, this time focusing on receivers. If you missed our write ups on Quarterbacks and Running Backs, just click on those corresponding links.

This is a position that might not have a great deal of star power at this point in time, but most of these names will play big roles for their teams this year. Most of the league's leaders from last year will return in 2011.

11. Antavian Edison, Purdue: He's not a big target; 5-11/175 but was second on the team with 32 receptions one year ago; the leader had 33 and is gone.

10. Brandon Kinnie, Nebraska: 44 receptions for 494 yards last year for the 6-3/220 Kinnie. Not bad numbers considering the average at best quarterbacks throwing to him last year...average at best related to their throwing abilities.

10. AJ Jenkins, Illinois: Had 56 receptions for 746 yards in 2010 with a freshman quarterback delivering him the football. Things should improve for everyone this year and Jenkins is the only proven pass catcher with Jarred Fayson moving on.

9. Da'Jon KcNight, Minnesota: McKnight is the clear #1 option at Minnesota, with MarQueis Gray moving back to quarterback. If Gray can deliver the ball, McKnight will build on his 48 reception/10 touchdown 2011 campaign.

8. Nick Toon, Wisconsin: He didn't have the 2010 he would have liked and battled injuries for a while. He had a 50+ reception sophomore season but just 36 one year ago. Wisconsin likes to pound the rock on the ground and he also had an excellent tight end competing with him for catches, but Toon is talented and could certainly move up this list by year's end.

7. BJ Cunningham, Michigan State
: 6-2/220 and had 50 receptions last season, plus nine TD's. Will have a chance to be the go to receiver this year with the departure of Mark Dell, however the Spartans have some young guns in the stable and should be able to spread the ball around this year with a senior quarterback and powerful running game.

6. Roy Roundtree, Michigan:
72 receptions one year ago and could have had plenty more. Was plagued by the drops in 2010 and bounced around from the split end and slot positions. He is 6-0/176 and has some wheels, but consistency keeps him from moving higher on this preseason list, until he proves it on the field.

5. Jeremy Ebert, Northwestern: He led the Big Ten in yards per game last year while pulling down eight grabs for scores. He's 6-1/185 and while not a traditional burner, he has a knack for creating a nice target against zone defenses and his quarterback Dan Persa is a master of delivering the ball in small windows. While he may not be one of the most physically gifted receivers in the league, he gets 100% out of what he has and his production speaks for itself.

4. Derek Moye, Penn State:
He's 6-5/205 and had 53 receptions last year including eight touchdowns despite playing the first half of the year with a true freshman throwing the football. He averaged 16.7 yards per catch last season, one of the best marks in the Big Ten.

3. Devier Posey, Ohio State: At 6-2/213 he was the second most productive Ohio State receiver last year behind the departed Dane Sanzenbacher. This year, once he gets on the field, he'll be the #1 target. He is one of the Tattoo Five for Ohio State who will be forced to miss the first five games of the season, but he'll miss just one Big Ten game. While he may not produce Top Three stats this year due to the suspension, he's one of the Top Three receivers in this league.

2. Damario Belcher, Indiana: He's 6-5/215 and one of the best in the league. Caught 78 passes one year ago, 25 more than Marvin McNutt who led Iowa, but had just four touchdowns and his average yards per reception was just 10.7. Look for the ypc and the TD's to go up this year as Tanden Doss is no longer around, as he elected to turn pro with one year of eligibility remaining (he was drafted in the 4th round by the Ravens). Belcher will be the marquee target but we don't yet know what kind of offense the Hoosiers will employ, and he'll have a new quarterback throwing to him as well as the talented Ben Chappell has moved on.

1. Marvin McNutt, Iowa: The 6-4/215 pound senior to be has paid his dues. He changed position early in his career, he had a solid sophomore season and then snapped Derrell Johnson-Koulianos' three year grip on leading the Hawkeyes with receptions last year as a junior. McNutt, with a record setting season, could leave Iowa with every major receiving record in tow one year after DJK rewrote the record books. For a 'running team' that's pretty good back to back production. McNutt doesn't melt the stop watch, but he has great body control, soft hands and shows competition speed; meaning he gets open and gets gone when he has to. If I had to pick one receiver to throw the corner end zone fade to in all of the Big Ten, I'd take either McNutt or the aforementioned Belcher. Both can jump and both fight for the ball. I'd give the nod to McNutt, because I have not seen him drop a game winning pass in the endzone.

resize.php
 
53 catches for 861 yds and 8 TDs is a very good season but not as good as some of the other players on that list.
 
You will regret not putting Junior Hemingway on this list Jon. I have a feeling he will do very well in the new offensive system at Michigan.
 
What does McNutt need to break records?

He needs this to tie the following career records...

Receptions: 85 (held by DJK)
Yards: 1070 (held by DJK)
TD's: 5 (held by TD and Dannan Hughes)

I think he gets the TD record. The yardage record is a stretch but it's possible. The receptions record is probably safe.
 
53 catches for 861 yds and 8 TDs is a very good season but not as good as some of the other players on that list.

I also take into account what teammates did last year, and what is coming back this year...Posey, McNutt and Belcher had teammates putting up big numbers...these guys are the key goto options this season.
 
He needs this to tie the following career records...

Receptions: 85 (held by DJK)
Yards: 1070 (held by DJK)
TD's: 5 (held by TD and Dannan Hughes)

I think he gets the TD record. The yardage record is a stretch but it's possible. The receptions record is probably safe.

Thanks.
 
Like the pick. McNutt has been great and I expect a solid senior campaign but it will be interesting to see how he and the Hawks respond to the focus being on McNutt this year. Many times underclassmen receivers will benefit from focus being on an upperclassmen. McNutt had to have benefited from this playing opposite DJK, will he be able to rise to occasion being the 'go to' guy? I think so. Also its possible some of the younger WRs in the stable will have a chance to shine this year as well. Davis is the obvious choice and I've heard rumblings about a few others (KMM Shumpert). One recruit seems to have dropped off the map, Jordan Cotton, I never hear anything about him. Is he not progressing as orignally hoped?
 
We continue our look at 'The Best in the Big Ten' series, this time focusing on receivers. If you missed our write ups on Quarterbacks and Running Backs, just click on those corresponding links.

This is a position that might not have a great deal of star power at this point in time, but most of these names will play big roles for their teams this year. Most of the league's leaders from last year will return in 2011.

11. Antavian Edison, Purdue: He's not a big target; 5-11/175 but was second on the team with 32 receptions one year ago; the leader had 33 and is gone.

10. Brandon Kinnie, Nebraska: 44 receptions for 494 yards last year for the 6-3/220 Kinnie. Not bad numbers considering the average at best quarterbacks throwing to him last year...average at best related to their throwing abilities.

10. AJ Jenkins, Illinois: Had 56 receptions for 746 yards in 2010 with a freshman quarterback delivering him the football. Things should improve for everyone this year and Jenkins is the only proven pass catcher with Jarred Fayson moving on.

9. Da'Jon KcNight, Minnesota: McKnight is the clear #1 option at Minnesota, with MarQueis Gray moving back to quarterback. If Gray can deliver the ball, McKnight will build on his 48 reception/10 touchdown 2011 campaign.

8. Nick Toon, Wisconsin: He didn't have the 2010 he would have liked and battled injuries for a while. He had a 50+ reception sophomore season but just 36 one year ago. Wisconsin likes to pound the rock on the ground and he also had an excellent tight end competing with him for catches, but Toon is talented and could certainly move up this list by year's end.

7. BJ Cunningham, Michigan State
: 6-2/220 and had 50 receptions last season, plus nine TD's. Will have a chance to be the go to receiver this year with the departure of Mark Dell, however the Spartans have some young guns in the stable and should be able to spread the ball around this year with a senior quarterback and powerful running game.

6. Roy Roundtree, Michigan:
72 receptions one year ago and could have had plenty more. Was plagued by the drops in 2010 and bounced around from the split end and slot positions. He is 6-0/176 and has some wheels, but consistency keeps him from moving higher on this preseason list, until he proves it on the field.

5. Jeremy Ebert, Northwestern: He led the Big Ten in yards per game last year while pulling down eight grabs for scores. He's 6-1/185 and while not a traditional burner, he has a knack for creating a nice target against zone defenses and his quarterback Dan Persa is a master of delivering the ball in small windows. While he may not be one of the most physically gifted receivers in the league, he gets 100% out of what he has and his production speaks for itself.

4. Derek Moye, Penn State:
He's 6-5/205 and had 53 receptions last year including eight touchdowns despite playing the first half of the year with a true freshman throwing the football. He averaged 16.7 yards per catch last season, one of the best marks in the Big Ten.

3. Devier Posey, Ohio State: At 6-2/213 he was the second most productive Ohio State receiver last year behind the departed Dane Sanzenbacher. This year, once he gets on the field, he'll be the #1 target. He is one of the Tattoo Five for Ohio State who will be forced to miss the first five games of the season, but he'll miss just one Big Ten game. While he may not produce Top Three stats this year due to the suspension, he's one of the Top Three receivers in this league.

2. Damario Belcher, Indiana: He's 6-5/215 and one of the best in the league. Caught 78 passes one year ago, 25 more than Marvin McNutt who led Iowa, but had just four touchdowns and his average yards per reception was just 10.7. Look for the ypc and the TD's to go up this year as Tanden Doss is no longer around, as he elected to turn pro with one year of eligibility remaining (he was drafted in the 4th round by the Ravens). Belcher will be the marquee target but we don't yet know what kind of offense the Hoosiers will employ, and he'll have a new quarterback throwing to him as well as the talented Ben Chappell has moved on.

1. Marvin McNutt, Iowa: The 6-4/215 pound senior to be has paid his dues. He changed position early in his career, he had a solid sophomore season and then snapped Derrell Johnson-Koulianos' three year grip on leading the Hawkeyes with receptions last year as a junior. McNutt, with a record setting season, could leave Iowa with every major receiving record in tow one year after DJK rewrote the record books. For a 'running team' that's pretty good back to back production. McNutt doesn't melt the stop watch, but he has great body control, soft hands and shows competition speed; meaning he gets open and gets gone when he has to. If I had to pick one receiver to throw the corner end zone fade to in all of the Big Ten, I'd take either McNutt or the aforementioned Belcher. Both can jump and both fight for the ball. I'd give the nod to McNutt, because I have not seen him drop a game winning pass in the endzone.

resize.php
Thanks Jon for jinxing Iowa and McNutt for this coming season. He's probably going to give you that dropped TD in the endzone now. geez!
 
I'd upgrade Jenkins and possibly Toon .. and then downgrade Posey and Ebert. Also, Roundtree is a pretty impressive player, however, I'm not certain if he hasn't already "peaked." A main thing that will potentially hold back Toon is the fact that he'll be having to break in a new QB.
 
I also take into account what teammates did last year, and what is coming back this year...Posey, McNutt and Belcher had teammates putting up big numbers...these guys are the key goto options this season.

I like Moye too.
Moye, Belcher and McNutt would be my top 3 (in no particular order) followed closely by Posey and Roundtree.
 
With the records within striking distance, I gotta think it would be nice if McNutty would break at least some of them. He will be given every opportunity IMO if he becomes close.
 
Although I agree with the assessment that sometimes guys struggle as the focal point, I’m not so sure DJK didn’t benefit as much because of McNutt as the other way around. McNutt IS the receiver….he is bigger, stronger, a better pass catcher and more consistent. Yes the reverse is always true, DJK did free him up to a degree, but McNutt can get separation, he will go up and get the ball, DJK never did (I still mostly blame him for that NW-Int) and he can hold defenders off with his body. He is a threat even with good coverage and being THE focal point of the offense. As far as that goes after 4 years of Soup Campbell I expect Iowa to have the best or near best WR’s in the Big 10 every year. McNutt is a product of that and Davis will be too.

Chad
 
Chad – You need to keep in mind that Campbell's reputation as a WR coach was built on a level of athlete at Michigan that far surpasses the kind of players Iowa is able to consistently recruit. Great players can make any coach look like a genius.
 
Top