With Kueter, I think it sells him short to characterize his success as the result of being a big fish in a small pond.
Going undefeated in HS at any level is relatively rare. Only six others have ever accomplished that feat in Iowa.
The National Freestyle Championships and World Championships certainly represent "big ponds." He is a former U20 National champion in freestyle and U20 world champion, and was the runner up last year in FS, barely losing to the Iranian.
As for the rest of this season, the lineup definitely is challenging. Steveson, Kerkvliet and Hendrickson are definite losses. I actually think he'll have a chance with Nevills and Andrews.
With his frame, adding 25 lbs probably wouldn't negatively impact his quickness or tank. A Ben Kueter at around 255-260 could be a beast.
Compared to his current peers in his weight class I think it's valid. As much as I love FS more than folk, it's not really very relevant for this discussion. The two disciplines don't translate when you're talking college wrestling, and Kueter is a much better FS wrestler than he is folk.
The guys he has currently in his weight class were as good or better when they were in high school and they produced right out of the gate to a level that Kueter hasn't yet.
The biggest reason IMO is because he's messing around trying to be a dual sport athlete. Today's a different world and there's zero chance he's going to be very successful if he doesn't pick one or the other. I know directly from a source that, shall we say, is what I'd call reliable without dropping any names
that Brands does not want Kueter playing football. But to get him in the program that was his hangup before he'd even consider wrestling at Iowa. Youthful stubbornness and ignorance, because at 18 years old you get it set in your mind that you're superman and can do anything. When one of the greatest wrestlers and coaches in history (Brands) tells you it's not a great idea to play two sports you should probably listen, but there was no changing his mind. It's just not feasible to skip a huge part of the season when the rest of the guys in the weight class are wrestling 365 days a year. I don't know how else to say it.
The other goofy part of it is Kueter is the absolute perfect specimen physically and stylistically for freestyle wrestling. He's stronger, faster, and more athletic overall than I'd say anyone in HWT folk right now including Steveson and Kerkvliet. FS is about explosiveness and quickness where folk is like we've said, about manipulation and control in position. I truly think if Kueter would shit can folk and football, and focus on freestyle he would easily be the next USA 125er in Los Angeles, and would give Zare and Petriashvilli a run for their money. He's just built for it but unfortunately there's not a real great way to make a decent living doing it in the US like there is over in the Spviet bloc countries. Most of the guys who do it here are living off pennies because they love it.
Unfortunately those things don't really translate into folk unless you spend all your time on it. Mason Parris was an elite HWT in college and got absolutely manhandled in Paris in the first round. There's a lot of other examples of it too.