1. Nobody knows how Gabe performed compared to Woody in practice. That was always a belief based upon the assumption that Fran promised Woody a starting spot, which we also have no proof of. It's one thing to make an assertion based on a fact. It's another to make an assertion based upon speculation.
2. You're exaggerating the level of hate that Gabe took early on. Most people recognized he was VERY rough around the edges, but had a buttload of potential.
3.. Gabe has a long ways to go yet. He has a higher ceiling, but he might not reach it while at Iowa. If there were ever a player that could have used a redshirt year, it's Gabe.