Would Kinnick make the team today? Position?

tweeterhawk

Well-Known Member
The Big Ten Network has an outstanding feature on Nile Kinnick in its Big Ten icon series. If you haven't seen it, it's well worth catching.

Several facts stick out:

- Kinnick was a not very imposing 5-8, 170 pounds.
- He was not particularly quick but worked hard, was smart, made the best of what he had.
- He was a halfback, a position at that time that managed much of the offense. He was the team's main passer in Iowa's 6-1-1 1939 season, throwing for 638 yards and 11 touchdowns as well as rushing for 374 yards on 106 carries (3.5-yard average).
- He also made 11-of-17 dropkick conversion attempts and scored 41 points.
- By passing, running or kicking, Kinnick was directly involved in 107 of Iowa's 130 points that season.

As was typical of the day, he played on both sides of the ball and played 402 of 420 consecutive minutes. On defense, he made eight interceptions. He also was the team's punter; several kicks were credited with pinning opponents well back in their own ends of the field.

He finished his career with 1,674 yards rushing, 18 interceptions and an average of 39.9 yards per punt.

As focused, size and strength-driven as division 1 NCAA football has become, with offensive players, defensive players, skill positions, specialists, etc., would Kinnick have a shot at being a Hawkeye today? At what position?
 
I actually think he probably could. Especially in our schemes, I think he could play cornerback for us. He would not be Spievey by any means. More of a Jovon Johnson-type corner.
 
I think he definitely could if he was trained the same way as athletes are today. Probably not if he just tried to walk on as he was though.
 
Would he make the team today, if he were alive? At 93 years of age? Hell. Yes. And he'd play every position too, as football was meant to be played.
 
Standouts are standouts because they work harder than everybody else. If Nile was playing in the modern day he would be the same type of person he was then. I would believe any person who was "the best" in their day would be the best in today's game. They were great because of their personality and drive to be the best. Nothing would change because of the era. They would be the same type of person and player today
 
A couple of things, first of all nutrician and training methods are better today so he would likely be a little taller and bigger. 5-8 was the average height of an american man in 1930. Today it's closer to 5-10.

I could realistically see him being 5-10 and 190 pounds or so. On the field I have no doubts that he would play. As smart as he was I could easily see him being a great safety at Iowa, and maybe even kicking/punting.

Nile mother****ing Kinnick has a nice ring to it :)
 
A couple of things, first of all nutrician and training methods are better today so he would likely be a little taller and bigger. 5-8 was the average height of an american man in 1930. Today it's closer to 5-10.

I could realistically see him being 5-10 and 190 pounds or so. On the field I have no doubts that he would play. As smart as he was I could easily see him being a great safety at Iowa, and maybe even kicking/punting.

Nile mother****ing Kinnick has a nice ring to it :)

Now that would make a great shirt.
 
i find it hard to believe that "nile kinnick" wouldn't be a starter playing in "kinnick stadium". hard to believe
 
i find it hard to believe that "nile kinnick" wouldn't be a starter playing in "kinnick stadium". hard to believe

You obviously missed the TV special. If Nile had known they were going to name the stadium after him, his humility would have "forced" him to find a way to prevent that.

And yes, he'd start at the same six positions if he were playing these days: HB, P, K, DB, KOR, PR

Kind of sad, though, that the Big 10 (pre-"Big Ten") was using his likeness on coin flips BEFORE the U of I, or as it was commonlu called, "SUI", named the stadium after him.

My question is, who the he&& in the Big Ten figured there were SIX people (let alone even ONE) more "iconic" than Nile Kinnick?!
 
If you take 90% of the athletes from those eras and just put them onto a team of the current era, IMO only 1% of them would actually play. Now, if they trained liked the athletes today then it would be a lot higher.

No, I don't think Kinnick would play today but if he grew up in this era his athleticism and todays training routines he would probably play.
 
Standouts are standouts because they work harder than everybody else. If Nile was playing in the modern day he would be the same type of person he was then. I would believe any person who was "the best" in their day would be the best in today's game. They were great because of their personality and drive to be the best. Nothing would change because of the era. They would be the same type of person and player today

THANK YOU, well said. I called in to KXNO when NFL QB's were being discussed, Perault scolded me for thinking that the Great NFL QB's of the past would also be good in todays game, some even better as we pass more now. He said that no Past QB would ever succeed in todays game. Pretty ridiculous, but what do you do.
 
THANK YOU, well said. I called in to KXNO when NFL QB's were being discussed, Perault scolded me for thinking that the Great NFL QB's of the past would also be good in todays game, some even better as we pass more now. He said that no Past QB would ever succeed in todays game. Pretty ridiculous, but what do you do.


Hypothetical.

Dont listen to KXNO, but I wonder if this Perault would be saying that if he were alive 70 years from now? Call him and see if in 70 years people will be saying that "there is no way Peyton Manning, Tom Brady, etc... will be in any good in todays game."

That may be, but it doesn't mean they're not the greatest thing going.
 
You obviously missed the TV special. If Nile had known they were going to name the stadium after him, his humility would have "forced" him to find a way to prevent that.

And yes, he'd start at the same six positions if he were playing these days: HB, P, K, DB, KOR, PR

Kind of sad, though, that the Big 10 (pre-"Big Ten") was using his likeness on coin flips BEFORE the U of I, or as it was commonlu called, "SUI", named the stadium after him.

My question is, who the he&& in the Big Ten figured there were SIX people (let alone even ONE) more "iconic" than Nile Kinnick?!

oh i saw the special. however you obviously missed the sarcasm and joking nature of my post
 

Latest posts

Top