Still waiting for that comparison Still. I find this Pretender talk to be ******* stupid..
I do, too. It's not really been my take; loess was the one who threw it out there, and, I've been trying to include it, alot, with the intent to be sarcastic and to needle the board a bit. I thought I made that point in the "Pretenders" threads last weekend ...
http://hawkeyenation.com/forum/showthread.php?74165-PRETENDERS-II&p=1494426#post1494426
http://hawkeyenation.com/forum/showthread.php?74151-Pretenders&p=1494443#post1494443
That said, I still stand by what my take has been from the git-go ...
http://hawkeyenation.com/forum/showthread.php?74151-Pretenders&p=1494132&viewfull=1#post1494132
Look, you seem to take issue with the derogatory connotation of "pretender" and cite the Hawks' resume, to date isn't that of a "pretender". I guess I look at that resume and see it being more a result of an over achiever that, when it all shakes out, can't sustain that level of success and will ultimately be exposed as probably not being a serious contender to begin with. I don't know if, by default, that makes them a "pretender". I'm quite certain it meets the definition of "not a contender".
That, to me, is what epitomizes Iowa - when they put it all together, they can have moments where they play at "contender" level but, the reality is, "they're Iowa". The same can be said of Penn State the last 2 games ... they are having a moment. Now, it's no where near the breadth and depth of Iowa's moment this season but, truth, we all know the moment will, ultimately, end; most likely, short of serious contention for a championship.
I take it further and say that, historically, Iowa's moments
seem to end in shocking fashion, when expectations are high and the lights are on ...
Sometimes before they even get started ... i.e. the epic disappointments that were 01-02 bball (Recker + Evans senior years, preseason #9, 1st round home loss to La State in NIT) and 2010 fball (nuff said).
Sometimes in such inexplicably poor performance that you seriously question how they were rated so highly and such that is certainly beneath what would reasonably be expected of a top rated team ... from 2006 BTT champion, #3 seed losing to NW State in 1st round to every Rose Bowl appearance, most disturbingly, 7 weeks ago.
Sometimes in gut wrenching, jaw-dropping free fall after achieving great heights and
seeming to have all the pieces to be a "contender" ... i.e. 2006 fball (5-1, ranked #13 to finish 6-7); 2014 bball (16-4, ranked #10 to finish 20-13 with 1st round losses in both tourneys); this season's final chapter is yet to be written but, the last 3 games are not encouraging. Not only have they been inexplicably poor performances, they've been progressively worse with each game, culminating in what is (and will remain) the biggest upset in the B14 conference this season, tonight.
Again, I don't "revel" or "relish" any of this. I'm a die-hard Hawkeye fan -- I don't get into pro sports, so, they are (and always have been)
MY team and have been for 42 of my 51 years. Over those years, not just due to all the examples I cited, above, but for the dozens of examples in virtually every football and basketball season when Iowa loses to teams that are significantly inferior in athletic ability, talent and resources, I've grown very cynical regarding Iowa reaching above expectation, consistently playing to ability and sustaining success. You can call me "miserable" (I'm not) and not like me or my perspective (I'm admittedly cynical, opinionated and sometimes arrogant but I'm really a pretty nice guy with a grounded outlook) but it doesn't take away from the truth that those examples continue to occur.
So, Pred, don't get bent over "pretender"; I don't consider them that. However, when push comes to shove, I really never consider them a serious contender.
It will be proven, one way or the other, over the next 4 weeks.