Ok, gotcha. I agree with everything you are saying except the bolded, and I don't totally disagree with that statement. Unfortunately, at the time of LP, he felt like he was helping the player by giving him a second chance, and it came back to bite him in the backside.
If you are saying that after the time of his assault, TO put LP back the field to win games (or specifically Florida), I would disagree with you wholeheartedly, and I think that history woudl support my opinion. If you are saying that he took risks with at risk players in the attempt to win games, I would agree with you 100%.
He absolutely took chances with guys like C. Peter, LP, Tyrone Williams, Riley Washington, Reggie Baul, Shevin Wiggins etc,. Did it benefit the program? Sure. But some of these guys actually turned their lives around and have become decent citizens. Some "at risk" youths that were brought into the program made very good decisions and turned their lives around in a positive manner, even though they were not major contributors on the football field.
Unfortunately, some remained screwups, and TO's reputation (and in the opinion of some, his legacy) took a hit. And deservedly so.