They ran that play against Indiana, with great success, in that famous Halloween game a week earlier. I remember McNutt crossing all the way across the field twice for big gains, one was like an 85 yard touchdown.
Northwestern wasn't Indiana, however. And Corey Wooten, the man who would later basically end Brett Favre's career, was waiting for Stanzi. What I hate about that play was that smug Pat Fitzgerald leading the cheers on the sideline knowing that he had not just scored a defensive TD, he had also knocked Stanzi out of the game.
Northwestern, and Michigan State for that matter, have always had a subtle way of giving the ball carrier's ankle a little extra twist at the bottom of piles. The did it to Stanzi that day and they did it to Canzeri in 2015. Did it to Weisman in '14 as well if I recall correctly. It's dirty, it's coached, and it's another reason I can't stand Fitzgerald or Dantonio.