Punting inside the opponent's 40

This is one of those decisions that leaves many Iowa fans scratching their heads.

Since the beginning of the 2010 campaign, Iowa has punted at or inside the opponent's 40 yard line 8 times (including twice vs. Nebraska).

The average subsequent drive by the opponent has been 11 plays, covering 52 yards. That's the average. Four of those drives produced points and there were no three-and-outs.

The decision to punt in that situation is one that's made to play the field position game. While that approach may have worked in the past, it doesn't seem to fit a program with a defense that cannot get off the field. Field position hasn't been the problem the past two years. Coveting offensive possessions has been. The Hawkeyes need to get everything they can out of those possessions because their number of touches is reduced due to Iowa's defensive philosophy (and skill level on that side of the ball). Iowa simply cannot punt inside the other team's 40.
 
Well, IIRC one of the times yesterday was into the wind (although I'm not sure that the wind itself would've had an impact).

But it seems obvious that Ferentz has little to no faith in his field goal unit during this time.
 
I guess I wasn't even thinking field goals. I'm suggesting that Iowa go for it in those situations -- especially when you consider the odds are great the opponent will reach our original line of scrimmage with ease in the subsequent drive -- as the stat posted earlier shows.
 
His reasoning is because 52 yards from inside your own 20 will force you to punt it back to us, whereas 52 yards from your own 35ish will allow you to attempt a field goal.
 
For what it's worth, five of those eight punts were touchbacks -- so 52 yards from the 20 puts the opponent on Iowa's 28. The opponent isn't punting from there.
 
My opinion is that once you pass the opponents 40 you should never be punting. Chances are the ball will be at the 20 meaning your reward for punting is at most 20 yards of field positioning (which can be made up easily in one play) and if you go for it, you just might convert and get a first down or make a field goal and get 3 points.
 
Top