Actually Shane I didn't like it when Paulus used it. But that is the current rule and Paulus set the precedent for it to be applied in this manner. The only difference was that Massoli had pled guilty to a couple of misdemeanors and had been kicked off the team. However, there isn't anything in the policy to account for either of those conditions.
Accordingly, if the NCAA made a decision based on those concerns, it would be ex post facto. Sucks, but it is what it is.
Accordingly, if the NCAA made a decision based on those concerns, it would be ex post facto. Sucks, but it is what it is.