Jon, your take on this story about press box cheerleading?

tweeterhawk

Well-Known Member
The Loudest Olympics Fans? The Hardbitten Folks in the Press Box

The press box at Kinnick used to be a pretty quiet place during games and I assume it still is; no cheering or yelling allowed, really not even applause beyond a clap or two. The SID or someone serves as an official spotter and calls out who carried/caught the ball, how many yards were gained, who made the tackle, etc., and that is pretty much it for noise.

That at least applies to the writers; the radio booths are another matter entirely and I'm not addressing that. There clearly was, or is, a point of view being expressed and perhaps wanted by the listening audiences. The TV guys usually play it straight, or try to, although at times that certainly is up for debate.

The WSJ story linked above is really more about cultural/ethical differences between U.S. sports writers and their colleagues abroad and needs to be clearer on that point, IMHO. Would be interesting to know whether there have been arguments or disagreements in the Olympics press areas over cheerleading by some. I know the peer pressure in Kinnick to remain mum has been pretty intense, or at least used to be.
 
Last edited:
..I seem to remember a lot of the Iowa sports media complaining on twitter during the Purdue game this last season (@ Purdue) and how filled it was with cheerleaders from the Purdue media..
 
..I seem to remember a lot of the Iowa sports media complaining on twitter during the Purdue game this last season (@ Purdue) and how filled it was with cheerleaders from the Purdue media..

I'm sure this will not come as a surprise to anyone but the Fusker press corp has the same reputation.
 
Many countries don't have a press that is independent from the government.

No independence --> No need for objectivity --> No reason to withhold cheering.
 
Jon has said before there is a fair amount of cheering in the press box at Kinnick on his radio show IIRC.
 
Jon has said before there is a fair amount of cheering in the press box at Kinnick on his radio show IIRC.

it would make sense. you want the team you cover to be successful, even if you don't traditionally "like" them. winning sells more copies. i think in the end, if you're a journalist, you just want the team you're covering to be interesting. you want a Rex Ryan, even if you think he's stupid, because he's a quote machine and makes your job easier.
 
For the 2011 season in Kinnick I can tell you it was a pretty subdued group. On the road I'm sure it varies, but the Iowa journalists I've been around are all pretty professional. On big plays there's usually some comments/gasps or "ohhs" and "ahhs" but no one screaming "GO IOWA" or anything. Phil Haddy the SID at Iowa did a nice job of curtailing the blatent stuff. Lot of other places I've been are a free for all in the press box.
 
Phil Haddy the SID at Iowa did a nice job of curtailing the blatent stuff.

It was definitely that way in the Fry years. Not from personal experience but reading a detailed article on this exact topic circa late 80's - probably in the once-great DMR Big Peach.
 

Latest posts

Top