I totally agree with you on the teams between 10 and 40 being that tight. I guess my point is then reward the team that's hot. I'm not disputing or trying to dispute the talent or who we play night in and night out. I just struggle, as an Iowa fan above all else, how a team that's gone 1-4 in the last 3 weeks gets the benefit of the doubt in the polls. In my world it would make more sense to see a team that's hot come out of know where than to see the team that's struggling hang around, and then if they heat back up again watching them climb back up the ladder.
I've always been one of those guys that feels you're never as great as you think you are after a win or as bad after a loss as you think type of guy, however I firmly believe that cliche of only being as good as your last game. So where I'm coming from mentally is I'll always feel the hotter teams should be on the up and the cold teams should be on their way down.