If I were Iowa this is exactly what I would've done

BSpringsteen

Well-Known Member
1) Kirk Ferentz issued the following statement:

I learned this morning about 12 of our athletes being hospitalized over night. I've spoken with several of the athletes in question as well as their treating doctors at UIHC. They assure me that that the situation is stable, that all of our athletes are responding well to treatment and that there is no reason for further concern.

Instead - we hear he is out recruiting. I don't believe for one second that the first question out of KF's mouth was, "are they ok?" He heard they were, that they were getting better, so why should he cut back his trip.

2) Upon the diagnosis becoming public Gary Barta issued the following statement:

We've learned that our athletes were hospitalized for rhabmylosis. We are in the process of speaking with strength and condition coach Doyle as well as the athletes in question to determine if this was caused purely by over exertion or if their were any common external factors between the hospitalized players. We will hold a press conference as soon as we have all of our facts, hopefully by the end of the week.

Instead we have a hastily organized press conference where a players father is the freakin star.

3) Upon the return of Barta and Ferentz to Iowa City a press conference is held with KF, Doyle, and the Dr. from UIHC

At this press conference, we hear details of the workout, and how it has been done in the past from Doyle. We hear explanation about what the diagnosis is and what the treatment is. We hear what protocol is for keeping players in shape while not in formal workouts. We hear about what kind of supplements many of the Iowa players take, if they are suspected as having a role. We hear what the plan is or when a plan will exist to make sure this doesn't happen again.

The bottom line is that a serious thing happened but was instantly taken care of in the right way. The players went to the hospital, and immediately got treatment and were never in real danger, despite having a dangerous diagnosis. This should never have been more than a news story on ESPN. Columnists should have never even wanted to write about this. Instead, we have this.

Doyle is right about something, someone needs to be fired, but it isn't any of the football coaches. It is Gary Barta. He has now presided over two of the biggest controversies to hit Iowa athletics since Pierre Pierce.

IOWA FOOTBALL IS THE CASH COW THAT FEEDS THE ENTIRE ATHLETIC DEPARTMENT - you have to protect it's image. Barta stinks at this.

If you ask me, Sally Mason ought to have a sit down with Barta and inform him that it is his *** on the line, as it is his athletic department. It is his job to oversee all of this.

Being a great AD is more than shaking hands and raising money, it is also making sure that your department is always being shown in the bes possible light.

This was a joke.
 
1) Kirk Ferentz issued the following statement:

I learned this morning about 12 of our athletes being hospitalized over night. I've spoken with several of the athletes in question as well as their treating doctors at UIHC. They assure me that that the situation is stable, that all of our athletes are responding well to treatment and that there is no reason for further concern.

Instead - we hear he is out recruiting. I don't believe for one second that the first question out of KF's mouth was, "are they ok?" He heard they were, that they were getting better, so why should he cut back his trip.

Agreed. Ferentz is on the recruiting trail, and this is an extremely crucial time for that part of the off-season. Signing day is coming up soon, and he may have been trying to land some necessary recruits. Aside from the fact that once he found out his players were in no immediate danger, he wouldn't have had any reason to come back instantly, you also have to think about what message Kirk suddenly canceling meetings with recruits would have sent to the players and their families. Can the Iowa program not survive unless KF is in Iowa City? Is the situation really serious?

By staying and keeping his appointments, he could assure recruits that it was just an accident, that it wasn't super serious, and assure parents that their sons will be fine at Iowa.

2) Upon the diagnosis becoming public Gary Barta issued the following statement:

We've learned that our athletes were hospitalized for rhabmylosis. We are in the process of speaking with strength and condition coach Doyle as well as the athletes in question to determine if this was caused purely by over exertion or if their were any common external factors between the hospitalized players. We will hold a press conference as soon as we have all of our facts, hopefully by the end of the week.

Instead we have a hastily organized press conference where a players father is the freakin star.

Also agreed. Iowa's most recent PCs have been neither immediate to prevent the circulation of damaging rumors, nor have they been planned sufficiently to provide enough information to dispel rumors or clear up the situation. We've gotten these slapdash press conferences that take place after the situation has already become a mess, and then proceed to only cloud up the situation further, causing more questions and rumors.

3) Upon the return of Barta and Ferentz to Iowa City a press conference is held with KF, Doyle, and the Dr. from UIHC

At this press conference, we hear details of the workout, and how it has been done in the past from Doyle. We hear explanation about what the diagnosis is and what the treatment is. We hear what protocol is for keeping players in shape while not in formal workouts. We hear about what kind of supplements many of the Iowa players take, if they are suspected as having a role. We hear what the plan is or when a plan will exist to make sure this doesn't happen again.

The bottom line is that a serious thing happened but was instantly taken care of in the right way. The players went to the hospital, and immediately got treatment and were never in real danger, despite having a dangerous diagnosis. This should never have been more than a news story on ESPN. Columnists should have never even wanted to write about this. Instead, we have this.

Here I have some issues...

1) You should still brought in a parent to represent the players and their families. They can not only talk about how well their son has been treated, etc, but they can also offer insights on individual players and how they ended up in the hospital. Neither the coaches or doctors can legally reveal that.

2) I think there are a few reasons they didn't have the S&T coaches there:
a) they didn't want the S&T coaches to reveal too much, and more or less put their foots in their mouths
or
b) they didn't want to reveal their S&T regimen. They simply may not want to reveal what they do, and make it public. It's kind of like putting your playbook up on the Internet, no?

Note that I'm not excusing the absence of S&T coaches, and I do believe they should have been there, but I can't see them revealing too much more than what Poggi's dad or individual players revealed (that one day they did upper body training, the next they did lower, had a couple days rest, did 100 squats, etc). They could have talked about the environment, and their safety set up though.

3) The supplements issue. While I agree that it should be investigated and dealt with, I'm not wholly sure you can reveal what individual players take, even if you know that. They should, however, have addressed whether or not the team gives players any supplements. Though, I can see them hiding behind confidentiality there as well.

This was a joke.

Agreed x100
 
Wow. A segment on Fox News just hammered the program. Some Doctor from Johns Hopkins in Baltimore just went off on the whole deal. I'll see if I can dig it up.
 
was going to write something like this today Bruce, now I don't have to. Concur with most everything
 
Transparency has been lacking under Barta. Sometimes the info has to be released to the public to squash the ridiculous speculation which can be extremely harmful to the long-term image of your program.
 
Whether you like it or not, BSprinsteen, they cant say the players have rhabmylosis. That violates HIPPA regulations. I guess they could have gooten all of the players to sign waivers to let them talk, but no one ever does that, so it seems unlikely they would have done that now.
 
Whether you like it or not, BSprinsteen, they cant say the players have rhabmylosis. That violates HIPPA regulations. I guess they could have gooten all of the players to sign waivers to let them talk, but no one ever does that, so it seems unlikely they would have done that now.

I agree with you wholesale, yet we know that players were admitted for exertional rhabdomyolysis, so somebody leaked that info. Or perhaps they just found out what happened to one player (such as Poggi), and just extrapolated that?
 
The more I look at when Iowa has been in the national media in the past year, the more I realize that we've blundered every time.

Barta is incapable of handling this, and even worse, he is incapable of fixing prior transgressions.

he needs to go.
 
I am seriously questioning the leadership of Barta and to the point of saying that he needs to be removed from his position as the AD at Iowa. The blunders over the last 48 hours have led to some damaging press and could have a major impact on Iowa football moving forward.

Barta is incompetent and his poor leadership is inexcusable.
 
Their PR department really handled this poorly. It is a shame, because it sounds like the coaches and doctors handled it very well, as did the administration.
 
This was an outstanding post boss. I think that what is even more damaging in all of the scenarios with the PR of this program is the reactive nature of the Athletic department. It is tiresome for them to constantly either (my perception) withhold info, or constantly be behind the story time after time.
 
March Doyle out and admit he worked them too hard and have him explain how it will be prevented in future... That is all you need to do. It is quick and someone takes responsibilty.. That is all people want.
 
Whether you like it or not, BSprinsteen, they cant say the players have rhabmylosis. That violates HIPPA regulations. I guess they could have gooten all of the players to sign waivers to let them talk, but no one ever does that, so it seems unlikely they would have done that now.

If they don't identify who was stricken with the condition they can say what the condition was.

The condition doesn't have privacy rights but the individuals do.
 
perhaps threads like this is why we have "incompetent" people in these positions? do you remember how long the last AD search took?
 
Top