thejumper5
Well-Known Member
Rodgers would be top-3, IMHO, along with Sam Bradford and Andrew Luck. The other two are younger, but Rodgers is more proven.
Eagles will win championship this year
- Thread starter hawkeye12345
- Start date
Rodgers would be top-3, IMHO, along with Sam Bradford and Andrew Luck. The other two are younger, but Rodgers is more proven.
trj
Well-Known Member
I will have to go along with this as well he has the precision and accuracy of Brady and the mobility second only to Mike Vick. He just has not done it as long as Brady, Manning, and Brees. My only concern is that he needs to stay healthy the concussions are worrisome.
ShadasRevenge
Well-Known Member
Andrew Luck = not in the NFL.
thejumper5
Well-Known Member
The person that started this part of the thread never said they had to be in the NFL. They said QB.
ShadasRevenge
Well-Known Member
HawkeyeMike23
Banned
I'm not disagreeing that he might not be the best QB right at this moment, but factoring in age I think it would be between him and Phillip Rivers if you had to pick a QB for the future. Manning, Brees and Brady are all great too, but they are also all on the downside of their careers.
ShadasRevenge
Well-Known Member
It will be interesting to see if whomever follows Brady in New England is able to do it the same way Rodgers followed Favre.
trj
Well-Known Member
Brady is 32 and has already stated he wants to play as long as he possibly can which means he will probably play at least another 6 or 7 years. You know if you even sneeze on Brady you will be flagged and/or fined.
Roethlisberger is only 29, granted many people think he is overrated, but given his age and the organization he plays for he probably has a couple more Super Bowl runs in him.
Manning has a Super Bowl run or two left in him as well.
V
VintageHawkeye
Guest
1. You unequivocally said Rodgers is the best, you didn't ask anyone to pick a QB and build an offense around him.
B. Since you want to play what-if relative to building an offensive unit, I give you...Matty Ice; Sam Bradford; Phillip Rivers (yeah, I think he's a tool, but he's got mad skills); Matt Schaub; Drew Brees & Roethlisgoober (on the old side, but both still have good years remaining).
Again, not a Rodgers-hater, not even close. Dude is talented and has a ring.
In my opinion he's not "the best".
"The best" active QBs, regardless of age, are Brady, Manning, Brees, Roethlisgoober, and Tebow.
busabus114
Well-Known Member
1. You unequivocally said Rodgers is the best, you didn't ask anyone to pick a QB and build an offense around him.
B. Since you want to play what-if relative to building an offensive unit, I give you...Matty Ice; Sam Bradford; Phillip Rivers (yeah, I think he's a tool, but he's got mad skills); Matt Schaub; Drew Brees & Roethlisgoober (on the old side, but both still have good years remaining).
Again, not a Rodgers-hater, not even close. Dude is talented and has a ring.
In my opinion he's not "the best".
"The best" active QBs, regardless of age, are Brady, Manning, Brees, Roethlisgoober, and Tebow.
I'm a Vikings fan and even I have to agree with Shada on this one. I can see arguing Brady, Manning or Brees but throwing in some of the guys you did there is crazy talk.
ShadasRevenge
Well-Known Member
woodyk1
Well-Known Member
No Jay Cutler? Sorry, could not resist.1. You unequivocally said Rodgers is the best, you didn't ask anyone to pick a QB and build an offense around him.
B. Since you want to play what-if relative to building an offensive unit, I give you...Matty Ice; Sam Bradford; Phillip Rivers (yeah, I think he's a tool, but he's got mad skills); Matt Schaub; Drew Brees & Roethlisgoober (on the old side, but both still have good years remaining).
Again, not a Rodgers-hater, not even close. Dude is talented and has a ring.
In my opinion he's not "the best".
"The best" active QBs, regardless of age, are Brady, Manning, Brees, Roethlisgoober, and Tebow.
HawkeyeMike23
Banned
1. You unequivocally said Rodgers is the best, you didn't ask anyone to pick a QB and build an offense around him.
B. Since you want to play what-if relative to building an offensive unit, I give you...Matty Ice; Sam Bradford; Phillip Rivers (yeah, I think he's a tool, but he's got mad skills); Matt Schaub; Drew Brees & Roethlisgoober (on the old side, but both still have good years remaining).
Again, not a Rodgers-hater, not even close. Dude is talented and has a ring.
In my opinion he's not "the best".
"The best" active QBs, regardless of age, are Brady, Manning, Brees, Roethlisgoober, and Tebow.
Anyone who thinks "Matty Ice" is better than Aaron Rodgers should not be talking football.
V
VintageHawkeye
Guest
No Jay Cutler? Sorry, could not resist.
I'm a Patriots and Panthers fan, Woodrow!
But I'm NOT a Claussen supporter whatsoever, and until Cam Newton actually steps on the field and performs, I couldn't care less about him, either. It's hype city down here, for Newton. I've already had my fill of the kid.
“Right now, we’ve got a lot of good looking guys standing around watching. Obviously, dreams aren’t reality, so the reality will come when I get my hands on them and we get them into practice and start grinding here like the other guys are grinding. That’s reality.â€
- Andy Reid,
Philadelphia Eagles head coach, discussing the Eagles’ heralded “Dream Teamâ€
- Andy Reid,
Philadelphia Eagles head coach, discussing the Eagles’ heralded “Dream Teamâ€
