Iowa St. beat themselves. Kirk beat Miss. St., good win, but not a huge upset. Kirk beat Ohio St., once. Great win, but didn't back it up. Not a lot of upsets by Iowa in the last 3 years. Been upset quite a few times. I guess most fans are looking at consistency, making the next level. Beating Wisconsin. I see the argument on both sides. Unfortunately, bringing Greg Davis in when Kirk had his pick of OC's left a bad taste in the mouths of many fans and then doubling down with his son didn't help, and the offense is still a mess, with a third year starter at QB. Honestly, Brian better pull something out of his arse or the noise will get louder.
I think you will find that KF and the hawks beat OSU handily and really crushed them in 2004 but I do agree with what you are saying that Iowa has lost more games lately they should have won than the other way around.
And as you say most of the time it is because the hawks are only scoring 10-15 points against teams like Minny, even though we have been beating them, jNW, Purdue, etc.
The hawk defense has played really well over the years except for the taxslayer bowl and that beat down at penn st a few years ago.