Michigan's basketball coach Dusty May called McCollum one of the best teachers and coaches in America at any level.
Marquette’s Shaka Smart said via McCollum’s Northwest Missouri State bio that he “really, really understands culture and what goes into winning from a people standpoint.”
“Then he’s a great coach on both ends of the floor,” Smart said. “And like the way that they play, you can tell he teaches guys and helps guys grow in how to play as opposed to little parts of the offense or parts of the defense. He teaches them to understand how to put it all together.”
When Drake hired McCollum, Smart added via the Drake press release that he “possesses a rare combination of tremendous relational skills, extreme work ethic, an innate ability to evaluate and develop talent and a terrific basketball mind.”
Texas Tech’s Grant McCasland said via last year’s Drake release that McCollum is an “elite coach in every category I know of.”
“He knows the game as well as anyone, both on offense and defense,” McCasland said. “But what separates him is the relationships he builds. That allows him to hold guys accountable to the highest standard of winning, but he doesn't just win championships, he builds programs that can sustain championship capabilities.”