I agree with you 100%. But as much as it pains me, 5656 is right about our senior and junior classes being awful and that being the direct contributor to our issues now. He told me that and I argued til I was blue in the face because I expected more development and instead, besides Baer - no one in either class is really contributing. The saving graces as you say is that our Sophomore and Freshman class look to be good, along with bringing in Joe W and Connor next year. I do expect some defections this off season though and I will be disappointed if there isn't an immediate plug brought in.
I argued it wasn't terrible because Uhl and Ellingson were both going to be average (wrong), Wagner, and Williams were both going to be average (wrong), and Moss was going to be good (Probably wrong). My logic was 4 pretty good role players and one good player over two classes was too good to be labeled terrible. 5656 didn't prove us wrong, Uhl, Ellingson, Williams, Wagner, and Moss did.