Wait, do you mean the only Iowa player to score, or the only player from either team to score? There has to be other games where only the kicker scored for Iowa.
actually forgot about that game, meant to add score a TD. But you are correct about Schlicher and on the right track for the answer I was looking for. I screwed up how I asked the question.
Hawks successfully pulled off the fake FG in the 54-28 thumping of Illinois back in Hayden's tenure. Jim Hartlieb was the holder and after the fake he threw the TD to future politician Matt Whitaker.
That was one of the most entertaining games I ever remember watching.