Uthoff's Decision a Midsummer Reminder

JonDMiller

Publisher/Founder
Cedar Rapids Jefferson prep basketball player Jarrod Uthoff had narrowed his choices down to Iowa, Iowa State, UNI, Butler, Illinois and Wisconsin. Indiana, Virginia, Arizona State and others had also extended him scholarship offers.

That’s a pretty impressive list to chose from for a player that came somewhat out of nowhere over the course of the last six months, but that can happen at this juncture of a basketball player’s career.

Iowa’s Fran McCaffery and Iowa State’s Fred Hoiberg have not been at their respective posts for even four months, so they had to get familiar with Uthoff and vice versa in a hurry.

Uthoff has family ties to ISU; his uncle is their all time leading rebounder. With Iowa, Uthoff would be some 30 minutes away from Carver Hawkeye Arena.

Uthoff chose to blaze his own trail and chose Wisconsin.

I’d like to say he chose the road less traveled, but unfortunately as it relates to the best prep talent in the state as of late, that road has too many travelers on it.

Jason Bohannon left Iowa for Wisconsin five years ago at the tail end of the Steve Alford era. That felt like a slap in the face to Iowa fans. Not one of disrespect, just one of an emerging reality of where the program had fallen.
We are all too familiar with that ‘reality’ now, and were hopeful that a change in head coach would immediately usher in a total paradigm shift related to the program.

The fact is that is not going to happen overnight. Rob Howe of HawkeyeInsider.com wrote a good piece on this linked here.

When I learned of Uthoff’s decision last night, I felt many of the things that Howe wrote about.

“It’s gonna be a long road,†was the first thing that came to my mind.
As much as we want to see the state’s best and brightest stay here, it might take McCaffery bringing in players from back east or elsewhere, get his up-tempo system off and running and show real signs of progress and success before the local players decide to come back. More than anyone, they are familiar with the shortcomings that has befallen Iowa and Iowa State, where UNI and Drake have had more success in the past three years than the ‘Big Two’.

Was Uthoff going to be a program changing recruit? No. Would he have been a piece of the greater puzzle? Yes. Losing him to Wisconsin, and having to watch him play and likely blossom under Bo Ryan at Wisconsin, the way we did with Jason Bohannon, will not be fun to watch.

However, Bohannon would not have enjoyed the success he had in Wisconsin, at Iowa. His career arc would probably be similar to that of Matt Gatens. I believe Gatens could have enjoyed an identical career to Bohannon had he been in Wisconsin’s system. But at Iowa, with so many defections during his career, he has been forced to try to play a role he is not suited for, and that is ‘being the man’ on the court in a scoring fashion. I am not talking about anything other than basketball here. But I certainly respect Matt for gutting things out during one of the most tumultuous times in Iowa basketball history.
It’s going to be up to Fran McCaffery and his staff to show signs of life this year, signs of excitement, so they don’t miss out on the in state crop of talent for 2012.

The in state kids are likely going to take a ‘Show Me’ stance as it relates to the Iowa program, and I don’t think anyone in their right mind can blame them.

That being said, I believe McCaffery will do that, even next year when the team will likely struggle to finish any higher than ninth or tenth in the league.
We knew it was going to take some time and there would be bumps along the way. But Uthoff’s decision, amidst the positive build up to what could be an historic football season, was a reminder of the work that faces McCaffery and the Iowa basketball program.

I could have done without that for a few more months.
 
I've lived in Texas for almost 5 years and the talent here compared to Iowa is night and day. I was sheltered in my own little world growing up playing basketball in Iowa and watching basketball in Iowa. It's another world down here. It makes me wonder If Iowa can recruit players like I see here in Texas. If Iowa can't even lock down the best in state talent, how can they recruit the best out of state talent? It's going to take time, but I'm tired of waiting....**sigh***
 
With a program like Iowa right now, it takes some kids who want to be part of the rebuilding process as opposed to coming into an established program. It's a mindset - Do I want to take on the challenge of building something from scratch or do I want the safer route of going with a currently winning program? Some people go to work for IBM for their careers, and some start up companies and either boom or bust. Both have their benefits and their burdens.
 
I think you are right in saying it might be a while until Iowa can lock down the in-state talent. It won't help if Hoiberg's risky experiment works.

So, I say don't put your efforts into doing that at this point. Paige and company know you want them. But, you won't get any of them if you don't turn things around quickly.

My blueprint for 2011 recruiting.

1) Find a JUCO or Foreign big man who can come in and dominate from day one. You don't need this guy forever. You need him to get you to the dance in 2011/2012.

2) Find an athletic 2/3 who can rotate with Marble. (Coleman would be ideal)

3) Find a versatile forward who can spell Basabe and number 1.

4) Both 2 and 3 need to have at least one skill set that can contribute from day one.

5) Pray that Basabe and Marble develop into All-Big Ten players. Third-team would be okay.

6) Do 1-5 well enough so that May and McCabe end up being numbers 8 and 9 off the bench. You need this type of depth in the Big Ten and these guys would be able to give the team instant energy and they would be crowd favorites.

7) Pray every day that the 2012 kids from Iowa do not sign LOI's during the November 2011 signing period.
 
Last edited:
I think it will be easier to recruit kids from outside the Big 10 footprint for awhile. First, the staff's primary connections are from outside the region. Second, these kids have absolutely no knowledge of Iowa, which frankly at this point is a good thing. The local kids have grown up watching this train-wreck of a basketball program, declining fan support, and the general idea that Iowa basketball is not cool. Kids from Philly, NYC, ect... do not know this, nor do they care.

It also seems that many urban kids value coaching relationships more so than some of our local kids who put more of an emphasis on the program. The kids that are more "coach-focused" approach really want to play for a coach they trust and have a great relationship with. We don't need to be a great program for our coaches to develop great relationships. That is why Basabe is here and why Coleman lists us as his current front-runner.
 
Although I'm disappointed we didn't receive his services, this might be a blessing in disguise. You look at the other offers, all those other schools play "slow ball". Iowa and IA State were the only two schools who offered that are going to play up tempo. So, Jarrod made the right decision. Hopefully we can bring in some guys who will be better suited for the Fran wants to play.
 
I agree with Homes and other comments made. Fran has assembled what appears to be a very good staff for recruiting. Even with that said, kids looking for the safe environment may not commit right now to Iowa. Lets face it, Wisconsin is a known commodity, Iowa is far from that.

It is more likely Fran will have to load up with athletic talent from areas his staff is familiar with and more well known. These kids may be more likely to take a chance. Fran should be looking for "his" type of player, not ours or what makes us feel good.

He has to deliver results, and if he does, in state talent will be back, but that may be post 2012 class.

Basabe looks good. We have a full roster with good walk on talent. Lets see if Fran can add 2-3 more athletic kids who have an open mind and an upside.
 
Maybe I'm missing the boat on him but is he really that good?He has a lot of filling out to do if he is going to bang with the big guys inside.I have confidence in this coaching staff to turn it around so they must of seen something in him to offer.I just don't see it as a big lost to Iowa, other than I wish he picked UNI if not us.
 
Maybe I'm missing the boat on him but is he really that good?He has a lot of filling out to do if he is going to bang with the big guys inside.I have confidence in this coaching staff to turn it around so they must of seen something in him to offer.I just don't see it as a big lost to Iowa, other than I wish he picked UNI if not us.

My feeling is that he will be a spot contributor as a frosh while he is filling out. He will play a bigger role as a sophomore and be at his potential in year three. No way Iowa could wait that long. If he came to Iowa he would be rushed into action, or people would expect more than he was ready to deliver. Iowa has been playing guys that weren't ready to play big minutes for a long time. Uthoff was smart to not step into that situation. Iowa needs guys who are physically ready to play right now. Then they can build depth and bring in guys that need to develop.
 
Maybe I'm missing the boat on him but is he really that good?He has a lot of filling out to do if he is going to bang with the big guys inside.I have confidence in this coaching staff to turn it around so they must of seen something in him to offer.I just don't see it as a big lost to Iowa, other than I wish he picked UNI if not us.

a lot of programs way better than iowa think so.
 
I agree with those saying tht out of the area recruits are going to be big in this turn around.

I also would like to add that i think in state recruiting will pick up once kids have a chance to see they style in place and players having fun with it.
 
I think you are right in saying it might be a while until Iowa can lock down the in-state talent. It won't help if Hoiberg's risky experiment works.

So, I say don't put your efforts into doing that at this point. Paige and company know you want them. But, you won't get any of them if you don't turn things around quickly.

My blueprint for 2011 recruiting.

1) Find a JUCO or Foreign big man who can come in and dominate from day one. You don't need this guy forever. You need him to get you to the dance in 2011/2012.

2) Find an athletic 2/3 who can rotate with Marble. (Coleman would be ideal)

3) Find a versatile forward who can spell Basabe and number 1.

4) Both 2 and 3 need to have at least one skill set that can contribute from day one.

5) Pray that Basabe and Marble develop into All-Big Ten players. Third-team would be okay.

6) Do 1-5 well enough so that May and McCabe end up being numbers 8 and 9 off the bench. You need this type of depth in the Big Ten and these guys would be able to give the team instant energy and they would be crowd favorites.

7) Pray every day that the 2012 kids from Iowa do not sign LOI's during the November 2011 signing period.

I like this plan. I'm not seeing our salvation right now coming from within the Iowa borders or even from other B10 states, for that matter. Find the East Coast or Southeast game-changer who doesn't want to stay in that area, sell 'em on the idea of coming to Iowa City.
 
The instate elite players are rightfully leary of the program. Alford lost many players for myriad reasons. He drove Sean Sonderliter away in midseason if I remember correctly. I remember him blaming Sean for a loss to Iowa State when the fault clearly was his. Sean picked up his second foul with about a minute left in the first half. Instead of taking Sean out, someone else was removed. Sonderliter promptly picked up his third foul with under a minute to go. He picked up his fourth foul very early in the second half and had to ride the bench for most of the half. After the game he blamed the loss on Sonderliter citing him getting foul number four so quickly. Despicable. Who would want to play with such a cowardly coach. When Alford left as everyone knows, the cupboard was bare for Lick's first year. Lick did well with what he had that year, but his style of play was so boring and frustrating for the players that it became painful to watch. The partially full Carver would discourage anyone from considering Iowa. With the selfish lack of loyalty these days, players transferring or hoping to successfully jump to the NBA, it is heartening to see Cougall, sadly gone, and McCabe want to play at Iowa. That will turn around in time with Fran. What might be a consequence of the pitiful condition of the program is that we might not show much interest in players from Iowa and will look elsewhere like Philadelphia and on up the East Coast where Fran is known and respected. Same thing with the Chicago area where Fran is known and respected from his time at Notre Dame. The addition of the assistant coach from Texas is a brilliant move as Texas is a huge state and a hotbed for talented athletes. With some improvement and the exciting uptempo brand of Franball, we should and probably will attract quality out of state players. We might not be interested in Iowa high school athletes because there only a handful of four or five star players coming from the state. Barnes is a once in a lifetime situation. We have never, as far as I know, had the number one player in America before and will surely not ever again. It might be a good thing overall to avoid the treacherous pitfall of recruiting in state. There are literally thousands of better players out of state and Fran has the connections already established. Why waste time and effort on players that can be so easily persuaded to go out of state. This loyalty fiasco could be a good thing in the long run. We don't HAVE to recruit players from Iowa when we can get better players from out of state with loyalty to Coach Mac. I particularly like the family aspect of Fran and Marge inviting the players into their home for meals and interaction with the family. Many urban players come from very difficult home environments, and this might be the first time they feel safe walking the streets and are welcomed into the family, Fran and Marge's and the Hawkeye faithful.
 
Last edited:
My feeling is that he will be a spot contributor as a frosh while he is filling out. He will play a bigger role as a sophomore and be at his potential in year three. No way Iowa could wait that long. If he came to Iowa he would be rushed into action, or people would expect more than he was ready to deliver. Iowa has been playing guys that weren't ready to play big minutes for a long time. Uthoff was smart to not step into that situation. Iowa needs guys who are physically ready to play right now. Then they can build depth and bring in guys that need to develop.

I agree,we need guys now not 3 yrs from now if were going to get the fans in the seats.
 
My question is this:

How in the world do you expect recruits to want to play in front of 8,000-10,000 people (at best) every night?

At Duke, that fills Cameron Indoor. But that's Duke.

At Iowa, that is 50-65% capacity.

Fans do not want to watch their team lose every/every other night they play on the home floor. Not when you can watch it from the comforts of your own living room in HD. Yes, the game experience is a great one. Yes, that ice cream they sell at Carver is amazing. And, yes, you gotta love the $1 dog nights.

However, you cannot fault a kid for wanting to go play for a decent program like Wisconsin. Additionally, their coach is one of the best in the business.

Fran is going to make a difference. I have hope.

It is not like he has a tough act to follow.
 
I don't think i have seen this anywhere but could part of the decision be Mccabe and Basabe. I mean he has got to see them up close and play against them, maybe he saw a tough road to beat them out for playing time. Just a thought.
 
I would not be a bit surprised to see Uthoff redshirt at Wisconsin next year. They have been very successful convincing even McDonalds AA(Butch) among others to redshirt. Many of their big men have redshirted. Gavinski,Bergrenn are two of the latest. That may have even been part of what attracted Uthoff.
Unfortunately, Iowa is not in a position to red-shirt anyone right now...we need contributors. Cougill should have but Lick did not make it happen. We redshirt Angle and Archie...gotta be kidding me!
 
Top