This is a tough one, and now I understand the use of the word poison.
Vincent had a bad Sr year and is probably expendable as he also may not be very bright at test taking, and may find college classes even harder.
Cy "likes us" and "it feels like home" with us, but we don't really know if that is even a good thing. While he would for sure be a player, he's not for sure in love with us.
Hendy, who kind of wants to be here "now", is possibly controversial and certainly not of the same high character as the guys from the Catholic schools (based on what appears to be his twitter account). He may be fast, but he may be a little too fast off the field.
My vote went for CK.