Miller: Hubbard's Departure Stings

JonDMiller

Publisher/Founder
nthony Hubbard's decision to transfer away from Iowa before the school semester even begins and after the spring recruiting period in which he signed, stings...it stings quite a bit on a number of levels.

First, it's a big shocker to everyone I know. I heard Tom Kakert of Rivals on Des Moines radio over the midday and he was talking with host Andy Garman about his expectations for Hubbard for Iowa this coming season. I had a conversation with an Iowa fan this morning who was asking me about Hubbard and what I thought he could do for Iowa. Hubbard was playing in the PTL just two nights ago and gave no indications that he was going to be leaving town in two days. Kevin Lehman, his coach in the Prime Time League, called into Brommelkamp & Balbinot in Cedar Rapids on Thursday and expressed his shock to this decision.

It's a story that has shocked every Iowa fan and I am guessing everyone in Carver-Hawkeye Arena, too.

The first reaction some have is to spin...I have been guilty of that in the past, as it's human nature (for most, save for the Eeyore's in our lives)..spin it in a way that everything we had hoped this season could be could still turn out that way.

I just don't see it.

Hubbard was going to be someone that challenged for double figures each night in scoring and maybe even rebounding. He was going to be a starter for this team and be arguably one of its best players. That is how he has been presented all spring and summer on the I-Club circuit by the Iowa coaches themselves. Factor in something Rob Howe tweeted about, which is that Iowa was in a great position to get Matt Glover before Hubbard told them he was coming to Iowa City...a double personnel whammy.

So this one hurts...this is not a program that can afford such a loss any time of the year, much less after they can do anything about it to add to the coming season's roster.

It also stings because Iowa went out of their way and took a chance on someone that most schools would not take a chance on; someone with a felony on their record, someone that served nearly four years in prison due to their role in an armed robbery, someone who is 26 years old.

There is a reason why most programs didn't take a chance on Hubbard; they didn't have to. Iowa felt like it had to, in order to get a player of his caliber late in the spring.

The reality is Iowa's basketball program is a bit desperate right now and they took a chance that Hubbard's issues were behind him. By all accounts from those close to him, that is the case. However, there were plenty of skeptics among the Iowa fan base, and the program took some hits after taking Hubbard's verbal commitment. Fran McCaffery and Gary Barta were answering character related questions at every I-Club stop. They organized a one-time, get the sullied past questions out of the way presser in June, and took even more bullets for Hubbard.

They held up their end of the bargain after choosing to take this risk. While the risk didn't blow up in their face in the form of recidivism, it has blown up in what it means on the court.

Hubbard showed in the PTL that he could handle the ball. He had more guard skills than I thought he would possess and he could have spelled Bryce Cartwright some at the point...not for long periods of time, but some.

Now, Devyn Marble may have to slide back over and spend some time at the point, which is not his ideal position and will take away from his development on the wing.

Bryce Cartwright might be the most valuable player to any team in the Big Ten right now for what an injury could mean to his team.

Given Iowa's weak out of conference schedule, they could still post 8 or 9 wins, but getting six, seven or eight in the Big Ten just got a lot less likely. This program desperately needs some good news and a good and competitive season. They need to finish above .500 to be in the hunt for some kind of post season.

I am still looking forward to basketball season, but I won't lie and say this didn't feel like a sucker punch to the gut. I am sure Hubbard's 'former' teammates feel that way and I guarantee Fran McCaffery feels that way; he was recruiting in Chicago over the weekend, and not back on the home front convincing a player to stay. This happened out of the blue, and the fallout from situations like this tend to hurt the worst.
 
Does this mean he can play elsewhere next season or does he need to sit a year since he signed an LOI? Either way it stinks,but gonna hurt even more if he goes to Penn St or another school on the east coast and plays immediately.

I do not wish ill on the kid,but this does **** me off,and do think he made a bad decision.
 
Character!!!

Edit: Maybe it was a grades issue. Some have said grades came out yesterday. If that is the case then I feel for the kid. However if that is not the case then this type of behavior is disgusting. Saying he wanted to be closer to home is ridiculous. I wonder how long before the truth comes out. I figure it's a grades thing or he got caught doing some thing wrong. Why else would the university be so quick to release him?
 
Last edited:
I don't understand why there are no restrictions or conditions with his transfer. He's free to go where ever he wants. I know the whole story isn't out but that just makes no sense.
 
It's easier to accept this from an 18 year old kid, but this is a 26 year old man who really did a lot of damage and caused undue pain to a lot of Iowan's as a result of this. I wish him the best in the future, but I am extremely disappointed with Hubbard right now.
 
The no restrictions makes me think he messed up and Iowa has asked to part ways as much as he would like to leave kind of deal. Just a thought.
 
Personally I think there is more to this story.
Of course there is.

I'll allow I suppose for a tiny possibility he really did out of the blue decide he was homesick, or have some family issues, etc.

But in reality, there are two realistic scenarios here: 1) He got a better offer under the table. 2) He violated some zero tolerance rule Iowa put in place.

Nothing else makes sense.
 
Of course there is.

I'll allow I suppose for a tiny possibility he really did out of the blue decide he was homesick, or have some family issues, etc.

But in reality, there are two realistic scenarios here: 1) He got a better offer under the table. 2) He violated some zero tolerance rule Iowa put in place.

Nothing else makes sense.

Or he didn't make grades, realized he couldn't handle the academics and decided to bolt.
 
I'm not going to assume that he got into trouble until that comes out on its own. Grades seems to be the most likely answer, given the timing. And the university can't say that he failed a summer class, or anything like that. Which would explain the cliche explanation as well.
 
We really need to start catching some breaks. I understand taking a risk on someone but he may have cost us Glover as well as some goodwill towards FM and GB who vouched for this guy.

Still looking forward to a better team next season but this will not help.
 
Stings big time, Jon. someone mentioned that he might have received a better offer under the table. That doesn't sound feasible. The most logical reason would be grades and the timing is right, just after Summer school ends. Perhaps he realized that he couldn't cut it academically, but one would think Barta, Fran and staff would have checked that out along with everything else.

If it is grades, this is a blessing in disguise because it would have been worse to have him ineligible for the second semester, especially him being an essential part of the team before conference play.

Iowa City might not be urban enough for Hubbard, especially being 26 years old. It would be easier to adjust to a small university city just out of high school, not four years after one would have graduated.

A major slap in the face for Fran and the program. In my opinion a character issue, that Hubbard should work on if he intends to be successful at anything in life.
 
As far as grades are concerned, I didn't realize Hubbard was in Summer school. If he was perhaps he should have done the same as Cartwright last year and devoted his time to studies not the PTL. Priorities were not in order.
 
Fran was on the road this weekend recruiting, and an ICPC story today says he was out of town recruiting today and could not be reached for comment.

If you think one of your starters and potential better players is gonna leave the ship and you don't want that to happen, you are not out of town...so this had to be a total shocker and really begs a LOT of questions
 
Hubbard is one nasty dude if he didn't discuss leaving with Fran before dragging his sorry tail back home. It doesn't matter how good he would have been, we don't need someone with such extreme character and loyalty issues. Unfortunately this could have a very negative effect of the program and set us back a step or two. Makes signing Woodbury and Gesell all the more important.
 
I understand the out of town recruiting excuse. I would think GB learned from KF being away during the rhabdo situation and wouldn't make a similar mistake less than 6 months later. I think AH did something to violate the terms of his scholly and got shown the door.
 
I understand the out of town recruiting excuse. I would think GB learned from KF being away during the rhabdo situation and wouldn't make a similar mistake less than 6 months later. I think AH did something to violate the terms of his scholly and got shown the door.

I don't think those two are even remotely similar.
 
Top