Blind POY selection

[SpiderRico]

Player A
PPG - 17.1
RPG - 3.4
APG - 3.5
SPG - .7
FG% - 48.1%
3FG% - 44.4%
FT% - 81.0%

Player B
PPG - 17.9
RPG - 4.8
APG - 1.7
SPG - .86
FG% - 43.3%
3FG% - 35.7%
FT% - 81.7%

Player C
PPG - 17.1
RPG - 3.5
APG - 3.5
SPG - 1.9
FG% - 42.7%
3FG% - 37.5%
FT% - 69.6%

Player D
PPG - 17.9
RPG - 4.3
APG - 2.7
SPG - 2.0
FG% - 41.7%
3FG% - 34.7%
FT% - 80.2%

Who ya got?

 

[PalmettoHawkFan]

player A

can't stand him, but

the most efficient of the bunch, best overall #s

(sorry dm)

 

[franstheman]

Player c, player c!!!

 

[clicheusername3]

No team records? This isn't very realistic.

 

[HawkeyeMike23]

Player A

 

[LG210]

Unless we're talking pinball, I ain't picking the blind player.

 

[PalmettoHawkFan]

player a : 13-2

player b: 9-7

player c: 9-7

player d: 11-5


apologies if that hurts the blind vote (I'll edit it out if so)

 

[LG210]

A has the best stats. Not sure that would necessarily result in POY, though.

 

[STILLBUSTER]

No team records? This isn't very realistic.

or positions.

I'll go player D for overall production in all facets.

 

[hawkeye12345]

Player A or D....coin flip.

Player on the team with a higher winning % would get my vote.

 

[TritonHawkeye]

Player D

 

[JG10Hawk]

Whichever player is most efficient scoring, passing, and defending. Without knowing the A/TO ratios I'd go
1. A - most efficient scorer by far
2. C - better passer than D? A/TO stat pending.
3. D - better passer than B? A/TO stat pending & more steals.
4. B - best rebounder but setting up teammates is more important imo.

 

[1hawkeye1]

Whichever player's father gets the most face time on TV broadcasts.

 

[bcl20]

I was hoping that POY was "poster of the year"

 

[PCHawk]

Ft percentage gave Marble away.

 

[SamsonHawk515]

Player A will win it, best player on best team.

If Player C had buried a couple of game winners this year he might have had a chance.

 

[WindsorHawk]

Player A

 

[SpiderRico]

It's amazing to me how close, statistically, these 4 players are. Obviously, when stats are that close, voting tends to end up mirroring the results of the team.

 

[HawkeyeMHA]

My senior year I was one vote from winning it

 

[PalmettoHawkFan]

the other stats are close, but 5% for player A is a pretty big advantage in FG%

player D coughs it up too much

A 52 TO

B 48 TO

C 53 TO

D 78 TO