B1G Power Rankings for 12/16

JonDMiller

Publisher/Founder
These types of things vary from writer to writer or blogger to blogger. For me, I rank the teams as I see them RIGHT NOW and create the hierarchy based on that. These rankings are not necessarily the order I would rank these teams in if we were talking about end of season predictions. I will put one of those together just before the Big Ten season begins.
1. Wisconsin: Those of you who didn’t like this pick last week probably are less worried about it now. Look, I don’t much care for the Badgers but I have to call it like I see it; the Badgers are playing the best basketball in the Big Ten and they’ve faced the toughest schedule of any Big Ten team. At some point in time you have to tip your cap or you’re just a hater. They are undefeated and most of their regulars can hit from three. They aren’t Iowa State, but their makeup reminds me a tad of the Cyclones…other than the Badgers don’t want to run and can’t score like that. Their Achilles Heel? To me, it’s that 34.2% of their scoring comes from three, which is 29th in the nation. Just 44% of their scoring comes from two-point shots, which is 324th (out of 351) in the nation and 11th in the B1G (Northwestern). Yes, they are playing to their strengths and in this day and age of basketball efficiency statistics changing how people think about what and where to shoot it, the Badgers can get away with this. BUT..there will be the cold nights, or the nights when the Badgers are playing against bigger, tougher teams. That begins on January 5th when the Badgers host Iowa.
2. Ohio State: The Buckeyes will be 15-0 when they play at Michigan State on January 7th. Their schedule is rated lower than Iowa’s according to Ken Pomeroy and they haven’t played any Top 25 teams yet this year. They are a great defensive team agains this season and their biggest challenge this winter will be if Big Ten officials choose to call the grabbing fouls the Buckeyes have become synonymous with.
3. Iowa: The Hawkeyes lost to soon to be Top 15 rated Iowa State by three-points on Friday night in game they led for more than 3u7 minutes. It still stings to type that, I must admit. I am over the ‘fan reax’ of the moment and can see that game for what it was; a classic between two good teams. The Hawkeyes have proven they are going to be a good team this year, perhaps better than good. They are going to finish the out of conference 11-2, losing one game in Atlantis and at Iowa State, which is exactly what I pegged before the year began. They will enter Big Ten play with an RPI somewhere in the 30′s, so unless there is a cataclysmic collapse, Iowa will make the NCAA tournament this year. That said, just making the tournament can’t be the goal for this team, and isn’t.
4. Michigan State: This is where some of you will get on me, but I just haven’t seen much from this team. Gary Harris not being full speed is a problem and Kenny Kaminsky is still suspended due to academics. Still, their signature win of this season (Kentucky) looks less and less impressive as the weeks go on. I don’t want to call this a finesse team, but that’s what pops into my head at times.
5. Michigan: Heartbreaker against the nation’s current #1 team in Arizona. Still struggling with point guard woes which affects the entire machinery. Nik Stauskas though….he’s a stud. Hitting nearly 50% from three and averaging over 18 points and doing things off the dribble. He’s really surprising a lot of people with that element of his game.
6. Indiana: Things get murky here but the Hoosiers have more talent on their team than any of the teams yet to be ranked, though the loss to Notre Dame in Indianapolis is going to sting them for a while.
7. Illinois: The Rayvonte Rice show keeps going in Champaign, though they did lost to Oregon this weekend.
8. Minnesota: I still don’t see the Gophers being a contender this year…that is, a contender for an NCAA tournament bid, but they are off to a solid start considering what they lost from last year’s team.
9. Penn State: The Nittany Lions are that team who will beat someone they shouldn’t because of Tim Frazier and DJ Newbill. I know that I have written that before and I still believe it. That said, you can’t lose 81-79 to Princeton. I put them here over Purdue, Nebraska or Northwestern because they have the lone Pomeroy Top 100 win amongst that crew.
10. Purdue: 76-70 loss to Butler isn’t horrible, but this isn’t a great Butler team and Purdue hasn’t beaten anyone. They play Maryland Eastern Shore and West Virginia before Big Ten season begins. I thought before the season began that this Purdue team could make the NCAA tourney, as they were salty last year and looked poised for a step. So far this year, I would not say that and they seem to have chemistry issues. 7-0 center AJ Hammons, who many thought was ready to become one of the two or three best big men in the league, has not taken that next step.
11. Nebraska: For all of the chatter (and this means from Nebraska fans to me on twitter), what has this team done? Sure, they beat Miami but those are not the Hurricanes of last year (now 5-5). We’ll get a better idea of how ‘real’ this version of ‘Nebrasketball’ is here in a two weeks as Iowa hosts them in the Big Ten ten opener.
12. Northwestern: The Wildcats are 5-5 as they transition away from the Princeton style without players well equipped to do so, however they do still have some elements of the past. Drew Crawford is good, JerShon Cobb is getting there but this is clearly the worst basketball team in the Big Ten at this time.
 
Great read Jon, I am sure you hear this all the time but I still have Iowa behind Michigan State. Even though the Kentucky win is losing it's luster they still own a win over a ranked team, something Iowa has not achieved yet.

Michigan looks like a team that can beat anyone on any given night but also lose to anyone on any given night.

Nebraska scares me, they have a real good coach and with the amount of money they have invested into their facilities I can see them rising above Creighton and up the ladder in the Big Ten.
 
Great read Jon, I am sure you hear this all the time but I still have Iowa behind Michigan State.

Which is totally defensible and full of merit. It's your type of disagreement that makes the boards fun.

Something just isn't there right now for MSU, but doubt Tom Izzo at your own peril.
 
Based on the criteria being applied I agree with 1 through 5. The rest look about right but don't concern me as much. It ultimately should come down to the top 4 on your list IMO.
 
That game up in Madison is a huge game for Iowa. Don't want to drop a third game and beating a Top 5 team on the road could do huge things for rankings and seed.

Pretty amazing that of the Top 5 teams in the country, 3 of them are BIG ten teams. I think the conference is down from last year but the lower level teams appear stronger
 
Seems about right to me, Jon.

I see the league as not quite as good as last year.
Every team is flawed.
Wisky is pretty small...kaminsky and decker is not enough size in the Big Ten. Hayes does not look to be ready.
OSU- again, not a huge team, but Williams improvement does help. They have the most high quality players in their rotation.
Iowa- shooting rears its ugly head again...this time from the free throw line.
MSU- Again, not real deep after Payne, inside.
Michigan- young at guard, they looked good vs Zona. They might be ready to rise to the top by Feb.
IU- callow youth, Vonleh is the real deal,but it is Crean, afterall.

These top 6 are locks for the tourney, but, after that, more of a crapshoot....I think Minny with the two vet guards, and PU has lots of young talent....the rest are NIT ...Illini ect.
 
MSU- Again, not real deep after Payne, inside.

I wondered if they would miss the big guy inside that played so dirty last year...assumed they would just reload. I agree that they don't have that "presence" inside this year...so far don't have to worry about getting "racked" going to the rack.
 
MSU is a strange animal. Seems like starting slow and finishing strong is an understatement for them - they can look like total **** preseason and end up in the final four.

Seeing them at #1 this year didn't seem right, so at least that weirdness is over.

That said, even though Iowa has proven they can hold their own on home or neutral court - I'm not sure how we will match up this year.

The rule changes would seem to benefit Iowa, but I have a feeling Izzo will have them used to "appearing to be compliance" by the time we meet up with them.
 
MSU is better than OSU right now. OSU hasn't played anybody. I would put them behind Iowa and MSU ahead.
 
Rumor has it that MSU's Payne is afflicted with plantar faciatis right now. If that lingers, they are in trouble. Tjey do miss Nix inside. Kammisky and Costello are not tough enough, yet.

OSU is healthier and deeper....and play defense/run the floor like MSU used to...but not this year.
 

Latest posts

Top