If he got hurt during the season then I completely agree. You don't burn a red shirt and sit a 2 time champion on the sideline. But if he hurt it before the season, as I have heard someone suggest, then it was a catastrophic failure to wrestle him if he could have gotten an medical red shirt.
If the injury truly happened before the season then it is a catastrophic and embarrassing failure to allow him to wrestle when he wasn't right.
If it happened before the season and he knew he wasn't right then he deserves whatever criticism is directed his way. He made the decision to wrestle...
For live scoreboard data on all mats, this is the site to go.
http://s301.trackwrestling.com/tw/predefinedtournaments/MainFrame.jsp?sport=wrestling&TIM=1362936506250&pageName=&ie=false&frameSize=705